Class action suit over iPhone 4 antenna

Barely a week since the public got its hands on the iPhone 4, the first lawsuit over it has been filed.

Filed in the US District Court for the District of Maryland on behalf of Kevin McCaffrey, Linda Wrinn and others on Wednesday, the suit accuses Apple and AT&T of knowingly distributing a phone with a malfunctioning antenna. The iPhone maker and its exclusive carrier partner in the US are accused of a laundry list of infractions, including: general negligence; defect in design, manufacture and assembly; breach of warranty; deceptive trade practices; intentional and negligent misrepresentation; and fraud by concealment.

The class action suit is latching on to the reported issue some customers are having with signal loss when the iPhone 4 is gripped in a certain way. It's been suggested the problem is tied to the iPhone 4's design, which incorporates the cellular radio into the metal band running on the outside of the phone, right where most people put their hands when holding the device. However, it's still not clear if a software update to the phone would help with the issue. Apple has maintained that it's a problem common to any phone when held in that manner and suggested that customers buy a rubber case as a solution.

The class action suit says: "Almost immediately after the purchase of their iPhone 4 devices, both McCaffrey and Wrinn began to experience significantly reduced reception and performance when handling the phones as demonstrated in Apple's advertisements or as a reasonable person would handle a mobile telephone while making phone calls, browsing the internet, sending text messages or utilising other services provided by the iPhone 4."

As evidence of Apple's mishandling of the situation they cite the internal memo that was leaked to the web in which AppleCare representatives were coached not to provide warranty service to customers experiencing this problem. The plaintiffs were also not cheered by the news that when a reader wrote to Apple CEO Steve Jobs complaining that if he held the phone in a certain way he lost the signal, Jobs responded, "Just don't hold it that way".

The lawsuit is asking for monetary damages as compensation and that Apple and AT&T be prevented from selling similar iPhone 4's with defective antennas.

Correspondence from Steve Jobs

The antenna issue has also seen a marked increase in Jobs responding directly to complaints emailed to him from irate customers.

On Thursday, Boy Genius Report published a series of emails between one of its readers and Jobs. The reader — one of the original people to post a YouTube video demonstrating the iPhone 4's signal loss when held in a certain way — complained to Jobs about Apple's lack of a solution for the widely reported problem.

After the customer said he had "lost all respect" for Apple, Jobs reportedly replied, "No, you are getting all worked up over a few days of rumours. Calm down". When the customer asked not to be talked down to by Jobs, the Apple CEO responded that he probably lived in "an area with very low signal strength". When the customer pressed the matter, Jobs came back with "You may be working from bad data. Not your fault. Stay tuned. We are working on it".

It's not clear whether "we are working on it" means Apple and AT&T are remedying the low signal area problem, or if Apple is indeed coming up with a solution to the antenna "non-issue" (as Jobs described it to another customer).

In another correspondence with a customer, Jobs promised that in the future there would be a better solution to uploading high-definition video from the iPhone, according to MacDailyNews. The customer wrote, "What's the point of building in HD video capabilities when the compression upon uploading directly to YouTube makes the videos useless and not viewable? They're not even remotely viewable!!" To which Jobs reportedly responded, "You can upload them via a Mac or PC today. Over the air in the future."

The past few months have shown a steady rise in Apple customers who are emailing Apple's CEO directly with questions, complaints and compliments and receiving replies, which they are then posting to the web.

It's notable because CEOs of companies valued at US$226 billion aren't known to interact directly with customers regularly, and because apparently bypassing Apple's public-relations staff and customer service representatives is working for people who want answers.

Apple on Monday said it has sold 1.7 million iPhone 4 units worldwide through the first three days of sales.


Previous Story

iPhone 4: camera review

Mobile Phones
Next Story

Garmin-Asus Nuvifone A10

Add Your Comment 14

Post comment as

Boo posted a comment   

well.... maybe you have a point but you only play for a few minutes?

i see people playing games on iphones for hours sitting on the street even @ school... its pretty sad.


Boo posted a comment   

@ inurendo.. why sit there playing games?? go get some friend and sit there talking to them on your mobile, not play games on some phone.


inurendo posted a reply   

My, we do like to make assumptions about people, don't we? None of my friends are awake at 6AM.


Well then.. posted a comment   

What?? Did you even think before you posted...people who play games on the iPhone are "low-lifes"...

Just like the other reply said, do you think people would love to carry around a big laptop, that requires booting time, a bag and space or just a simple phone in their pocket with great multimedia capabillities?? I think you are the real "low-life" who can't afford an iPhone and just takes it out on the people who can..


really posted a comment   

name one decent phone nokia has released in years htc makes better phones and they about a thousand times smaller NOKIA SUCK!!!


Ange posted a reply   

Hi "really".
I thought your comment was intelligent and insightful. Humankind thanks you.


BOO posted a comment   

Iphones are pretty **** phones anyways , they good for people who play games on there phones ( sigh low lifes who cant afford a nice gaming laptop) and its all hype like come on you pay so much for so little , its like with the ipad, what good is it? its like half a laptop and costs the same price as a decent laptop.

Apple is just for people who have no clue about technology, the google phones and nokia are much better, and if your a business person a blackberry or a HTC is the way to go.


inurendo posted a reply   

Does that mean I'm a "low-life" because I play games on my iPhone while waiting for the bus instead of bringing my nice gaming laptop to work every day? Or that my mum's a "low-life" because she's not a PC gamer but likes to play Solitaire?

What precisely about not being able to afford a $1500 laptop makes someone a "low-life" anyway?


n97 guy posted a comment   

apple owners = SUCKAS !!!!!
Nokia ftw lol


totoaus posted a comment   

Squib could definitely take action against HP, with a couple of provisos:
1. Money - how will you fund this action? You probably know this, but courts are expensive. There are companies that fund cases like this, but I think you need to prove to them it will earn them enough money, that means roping in a bunch of people with the same issues.
2. Time - I think that phone has been out of production for a while. Your case may have been hurt by the delay, although if you have been constantly seeking help it may not. If you gave up a couple of years ago, and want to try again: the delay will need a good reason.

Also, I have used a fair bit of HP gear over the years, start with what is now Agilent test equipment in the mid 1980s at university, and in some jobs I supported their products. I personally have NEVER struck a bad product or poor service, but you have obviously had a different experience. They did once refuse to let me replace my PDA LCD screen, but I presume they had an issue with safety or material disposal. I let it go.

Sponsored Links

Recently Viewed Products