Join CNET.com.au: Receive free newsletters, post to forums and win prizes. Sign up now!

Reliability of USB flash drives questioned

By Asher Moses on 07 June 2006

Tags: drive | flash | key | lexar | sandisk | thumbdrive | usb | usb flash drives | device | cheap

SanDisk Cruzer Micro SanDisk's Cruzer Micro is an example of solid USB drive construction

According to a report issued by data recovery specialist Payam Data Recovery (PDR), cases of faulty USB flash drives are on the rise, growing at an even faster rate than unit sales themselves.

PDR reports a 300 percent year-on-year increase in cases of USB drives that have "suddenly stopped working," as a result of "faults, misuse and an increasing number of poorly manufactured devices on the market."

By comparison, 54 million USB flash drive units sold last year and sales are expected to hit 100 million this year (according to Gartner Dataquest statistics included in PDR's report), which would equate to a sales growth rate of 85 percent overall.

PDR's Managing Director, Payam Toloo, attributes much of the issue to owner carelessness, but also questions manufacturing quality.

"A limited number of write/erase cycles are possible before failure occurs, and while high-end flash drives will support several million cycles, cheaper devices are more unpredictable," Toloo said.

SanDisk, a premier USB flash drive producer, agrees with Toloo that cheaper devices are prone to quality issues.

"There are some manufacturers that produce lower end products that might become faulty after repeated use," a SanDisk spokesperson told CNET.com.au.

While the report failed to name specific producers of said "cheaper devices", SanDisk is adamant that it is not one of them.

"Under optimal conditions, the lifespans of [SanDisk] USB flash drives can be up to
10 years or more when used like a CD-R; when used like a CD-RW, the
lifespan may vary."

CD-R use involves writing data to the device once, and only reading that data on subsequent occasions. However, it's far more common to use a flash drive like a CD-RW, where new data is constantly being written to and read from the drive.

Toloo is optimistic about the prospects of USB flash drives as a "short-term" backup solution, provided that they're treated with care and not relied upon as the only mechanism for backup.

"The best way to prevent losing data from a USB flash drive is to invest in a good quality device, unplug it when not in direct use, keep it in a safe, cool, dry place and always eject properly through the operating system," he said.

vgupta001
24/09/2007 03:47 PM

I WANT TO KNOW, IF THE LIFE OF USB IS TOLD TO BE 10 YEARS OR SO, IF THE USB GIVES A WARNING BEFORE GOING BAD??? HOW THE DATA IS KEPT "ALIVE" IN USB DRIVES? WHAT IS THE POWER SUPPLY INSIDE THE USB, WHEN IT IS NOT CONNECTED TO PC?

Report offensive content

Diana Buckland
23/05/2008 04:26 PM

Hi there, I have never used a usb flash drive before and I need to now to keep photos of my art - so all I know is how to get my photos from my camera into the computer - how do I use the usb flash drive to get my photos from computer on to the flash drive - can you please give "idiot instructions" as my cyber skills leave a lot to be desired. Thank you so much, can you send the information to Diana Buckland dbucklan@bigpond.net.au

Report offensive content

  • Leave a comment

All fields marked with * are required

What do you think

Your e-mail will not be displayed

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars.


  • News

  • Features

  • Oi!

  • Must read

  • Apple updates Leopard to 10.5.4

  • Whaddyareckon?: Human-gadget hybrids

  • Intel announces 4 Series desktop chipset family

  • Hey, look! Full-size systems from Asus

  • Apple uncovers Sydney store for the first time

  • ASUS motherboard has instant-on version of Linux

  • HP to launch fall line of teen PC products

  • Dell announces major retail partnership with Officeworks

  • Magnetic bacteria 'factory workers of the future'

More news »

Find the right desktop

Brand
  • Multiple options can be selected

    The Explain Series

    • Conceptronic Grab'n'GO CH3SNAS

      Conceptronic Grab'n'GO CH3SNAS

      Conceptronic's Grab'n'Go NAS is a solid offering that comes with enough features to keep the home user happy.

    • Netgear ReadyNAS Duo

      Netgear ReadyNAS Duo

      The ReadyNAS range is a perfect addition to a household that needs not just storage, but control over that storage. Now if only Netgear could do something about the price.

    • Sony BWU-200S Blu-ray burner

      Sony BWU-200S Blu-ray burner

      If you're in the market for Blu-ray authoring, Sony has produced a decent device. Everyone else will most likely stick to their vastly cheaper DVD burners for a little bit longer.

    • Western Digital My Passport Elite (320GB)

      Western Digital My Passport Elite (320GB)

      Western Digital's My Passport Elite is a great little portable hard drive with an even better warranty to back it up.

    • QNAP TS-109 Turbo Station

      QNAP TS-109 Turbo Station

      Frustrating yet powerful, the QNAP TS-109 is a poor choice for beginners looking to add storage to their network but the patient will find plenty of useful features.

    More reviews »

    Membership benefits

    Manage and receive subscriptions

    Manage and receive subscriptions

    Choose to receive an e-mail update containing our best articles either daily, weekly or monthly. Sign up for a free CNET.com.au membership now!