Fans create petition to bring back Xbox One policies

About The Author

CNET Editor

Michelle Starr is the tiger force at the core of all things. She also writes about cool stuff and apps as CNET Australia's Crave editor. But mostly the tiger force thing.

Xbox fans have created a petition on to bring back the features and policies that Microsoft removed in the face of mass fan outrage.


The Xbox One has not been having a good time of it. Not long after the console was launched, Microsoft revealed heavy restrictions around sharing games — that is, games could only be transferred once between friends, a one-way, one-time-only gift, and lending games was off the table at launch. Users would also be required to connect to the internet at least once every 24 hours.

Amid massive fan backlash, Microsoft last month announced that it would be reversing these policies. Gamers would be able to trade, lend, resell and rent games; and the internet check-in and regional restrictions would be removed.

In return, however, some new features would be lost; notably, the ability to access your digital games library from any Xbox One using your Live log-in details, and the ability to share your digital library with 10 friends.

Now, a new petition has surfaced on to put the Xbox One back to the way it was. Called "Microsoft: Give us back the Xbox One we were promised at E3", the petition asserts that gamers did not understand what they were giving up when they rallied for the features to be removed.

This was to be the future of entertainment. A new wave of gaming where you could buy games digitally, then trade, share or sell those digital licenses. Essentially, it was Steam for Xbox. But consumers were uninformed, and railed against it, and it was taken away because Sony took advantage of consumers' uncertainty.

In a way, they're right: Microsoft's PR surrounding the new console was terrible, not placing enough emphasis on the advantages the new policies could deliver until after it had decided to reverse them. And it certainly wasn't helped by Sony, which deliberately played upon gamer outrage over the new Xbox One when announcing details for the PlayStation 4.

That said, Sony has still been able to implement digital library access from any PlayStation 4 console without Microsoft's sharing restrictions, which begs the question why the restrictions are required.

We're not sure where Microsoft will go from here. Changing policy once indicates a willingness to listen to consumers; changing it back again could be seen as weakness. Whichever way the company decides to go, however, one thing is certain: someone is going to complain.

CNET Australia has contacted Microsoft for comment, but had not received a response by the time of writing.

Add Your Comment 5

Post comment as

tjmulls posted a comment   

Written in the artical was:

"That said, Sony has still been able to implement digital library access from any PlayStation 4 console without Microsoft's sharing restrictions, which begs the question why the restrictions are required."

I don't know if you have every used an xbox 360, but it currently has a Digital Libary where you can download titles. What the Xbox One was trying to implement was the ability to then trade these digital titles with friends and family. (Which to date, Does not exist). Its a pitty that once again, the microsoft pr/marketing departments have let the company down. The Xbox one was truely going to be the "Next Generation" Gaming platform, but now its just an upgrade to the Xbox 360


RickB1 posted a comment


EesK posted a comment   

LAMO Sony fans?

Do your research (again) and you will find they were mainly Xbox hardcore gamers. Ugh!


RickB1 posted a comment   

Please don't bring them back if its linked to used games restrictions


StephenF2 posted a comment   

Easy fix For the first two weeks after releaseAdd a message to the initial setup asking early adopters what option they want to go with Most of the angry comments came from people on the internet which doesn't make sense or sony fans thinking that they see blood in the water

Sponsored Links

Recently Viewed Products