Google slams 'heavy-handed' filter

By Colin Ho on 16 December 2009

Google Australia posted a statement today on its official blog calling the government's ISP filter "heavy handed" and outlining the search giant's concerns about the scope of filtered content.

Moving to a mandatory ISP filtering regime with a scope that goes well beyond such material is heavy handed

Google Australia

Google's major concern is that the scope of filtered refused classification content is too wide, citing a recent report by Australian media academics, professors Catharine Lumby, Lelia Green and John Hartley.

The report found that adults may be refused access to material which is legally classifiable under Australian law. Potentially blocked material could include videos of political assassinations, graffiti art tutorials and drug use.

"Moving to a mandatory ISP filtering regime with a scope that goes well beyond such material is heavy handed and can raise genuine questions about restrictions on access to information," Google wrote in the statement.

Google stated that whilst limits should be placed on extreme material such as child pornography, the company has a bias in favour of people's right to free expression.

"While we recognise that protecting the free exchange of ideas and information cannot be without some limits, we believe that more information generally means more choice, more freedom and ultimately more power for the individual," posted Google.

ZDNet.com.au asked the head of Google's Policy Team, Iarla Flynn, if the ISP filter will affect the company.

"It's hard to say because the details of how this will actually work have not fully emerged," said Flynn. "We think there could be an impact, and if you're asking if there's material today which could be refused classification material ... the answer to that is yes."

Google also called for more debate and awareness of the filter issue in its post.

"Exposing politically controversial topics for public debate is vital for democracy. Homosexuality was a crime in Australia until 1976 in ACT, NSW in 1984 and 1997 in Tasmania," wrote Google, "Political and social norms change over time and benefit from intense public scrutiny and debate. The openness of the internet makes this all the more possible and should be protected."

Topics: google, internet filter, isp, flynn

Related Articles

Comments (5)

  • WTF commented on 21/12/2009 01:10

    its not discussed be cause there is no mainstream outlets willing to discuss this stuff i mean abc had its funding slashed last time it questioned the government

    greens for senate

  • blaze commented on 17/12/2009 04:08

    and we look at china and say"How could they do that"? and we go and do the same thing,kevin rudd wants faster Internet(Which is Good) but what will be the point of having better service when theres nothing to look at?

  • Aussiedude commented on 17/12/2009 00:04

    DAMN RIGHT GOOGLE!

    I can't urge people enough to discuss this matter and get it into the public debate, and for people to realise how serious an issue this is. A filtering system is a step backwards! It's a horrible idea!

    A filtering system or any form of censorship kills democracy.

  • daniel commented on 16/12/2009 19:38

    Google, and all the other companies that willingly take part in China's firewalls and oppressive policies, have NO SAY in this matter.

  • Cam commented on 16/12/2009 20:36

    Google may be somewhat hypocritical in this, I agree, but their point stands. This filter has the potential to do considerable damage to free speech and education in this country, while failing to address the issue of abhorrent material which it is supposed to deal with. Censorship should be applied with a light touch. Many examples of previously censored or banned material exist (eg. 'Lady Chatterley's Lover') which have later proved to be entirely harmless, and in the case of the example mentioned, have been acknowledged as a minor classic. Heavy handed censorship is more likely to lead to ignorance and bigotry, than to help society.

Post your own comment

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 & A..F

Submit

Enter your personal information to the left, or sign in with your Facebook account by clicking the button below.

Connect

Most Popular

Resource Centre Useful content from our premier sponsors

GetPrice Useful content from our premier sponsors

CNET Australia
Compare more prices