iPhone 5 vs. Galaxy S3 4G vs. One XL

About The Author

CNET Editor

Joe capitalises on a life-long love of blinking lights and upbeat MIDI soundtracks covering the latest developments in smartphones and tablet computers. When not ruining his eyesight staring at small screens, Joe ruins his eyesight playing video games and watching movies. Twitter: @Joseph_Hanlon

Apple's iPhone 5 will join an exclusive collection of smartphones in Australia when it launches on 21 September, being one of only a handful of 4G-capable phones available at this time. We thought we'd take a closer look at how it compares with the current 4G king, the HTC One XL, and the highly anticipated Samsung Galaxy S III (GS3) 4G.

This isn't an exhaustive list of 4G phones available in Australia, though. Telstra has committed to five new 4G phones by Christmas, of which we know two will be the upcoming Motorola Razr HD and Razr M. For its part, Optus has only announced the GS3 and iPhone 5 for its new 4G network so far, and we expect to see more from the telco in the very near future.

Apple iPhone 5

Samsung Galaxy S3 4G

4-inch IPS LCD
640x1136 pixels
4.8-inch Super AMOLED
720x1280 pixels
4.7-inch Super IPS LCD
720x1280 pixels
Apple A6
Unknown clock speed
Samsung Exynos
Quad-core 1.2GHz
Qualcomm S4
Dual-core 1.5GHz
16GB, 32GB and 64GB options 16GB and 32GB 32GB
Non-expandable memory MicroSD card slot Non-expandable memory
7.6mm thick
112 grams
8.6mm thick
133 grams
8.9mm thick
129 grams
8-megapixel BSI camera 8-megapixel BSI camera 8-megapixel BSI camera

Bigger battery, better

As you can see in the table above, there isn't that much separating these three models. Samsung has the largest screen by a hair, Apple offers the phone with the highest storage capacity and they all share the same networking features.

What should tell them apart is how long you can use the phone for between charges. We already have enough evidence to tell us that the One XL is out of the race on this metric. HTC's choice of an 1850mAh battery just doesn't compare with the 2100mAh capacity unit in the GS3. In true Apple fashion, we haven't been told how big the battery in the iPhone 5 is, and we'll probably have to wait until someone breaks one open to find out. Apple made some decent-sounding battery life claims during its keynote, including 8 hours of talk time and 40 hours of music playback, but battery life is always a combination of several factors working together.

This is also one area where the new Motorolas could get a look-in. The Razr HD has a 2500mAh battery on-board, which is the largest of any phone of this size (the Samsung Galaxy Note has a 3100mAh battery, but this is offset by its giant screen). Even the Razr M has a 2000mAh battery, placing it on paper in front of the HTC XL. The Razr M will also have a 4-inch screen for those considering the iPhone 5 for its compact size.

Add Your Comment 16

Post comment as

EesK posted a comment   

You can get the Sammy S111 4G via Mobicity Hong Kong unlocked and then get a BYO Plan from Telstra now. I also got a 32GB microSD class 10 and a nifty little leather vertical flip case (but not from mobicity, there are much better leather flip cases out there) Bear in mind, I live in the CBD so I have constant access to Telstra 4G.


dkraka posted a reply   

How do you go to mobicity hong kong from australia i can't seem to find the 4g version of galaxy s3


dkraka posted a reply   

how do you go to the hong kong site from australia as i cant find the s3 4g from the australian website


MichaelS12 posted a comment   

When is the 4G galaxy s3 going to be available through Telstra?


garrfish posted a comment   

Hmmm, while apple does offer the highest on-board storage, "highest storage capacity" would include the capability to add storage, therefore i would argue that sammy wins there....


meme11 posted a comment   

Razr M has 4.3 inch screen, not 4. Also, isn't the HTC Velocity 4G phone available?

Sponsored Links

Recently Viewed Products