Design
For as long as they've been around, the ThinkPad line (previously IBM, now Lenovo) have been the Volvos of the notepad world. To borrow shamelessly from Dudley Moore's Crazy People, "they're boxy -- but they're good". That design idea has carried on throughout the ThinkPad's life and it's ensured legions of enterprise buyers have continued being buyers of ThinkPads.
On the consumer end of the spectrum, however, Lenovo's had less success and a lot of that has come down to design issues. Or, to put it more succinctly, their consumer notebooks have looked ugly and often appeared cheap. The IdeaPad line, thankfully, erases that perception; while it takes a lot from the ThinkPad line in terms of design, it's also packed with enough neat consumer touches to make it stand out. This isn't a wholly blinged-out consumer system -- but it's also not just a boring black box.
From the outside the IdeaPad doesn't seem that special, aside from the textured cover, which has the nice side effect of not picking up finger smudges. Opening it up reveals that the screen doesn't sit on the usual thin hinge, but instead rotates off a roughly L-shaped stand, which pushes the 15.4" TFT display back a touch. Lenovo refers to the IdeaPad as having a "frameless" screen, but that's not exactly true. It does lack a protruding bezel -- the glass of the screen floats to the edge -- but there's still a 1cm black frame behind the glass. At 360mm x 262mm x 36.2mm and with a carrying weight of 2.96kg, this isn't a massively portable machine per se.
Features
The IdeaPad submitted to CNET.com.au for review was the Y510-300 model, which ships with an Intel Core 2 Duo processor T9300 running at 2.50Ghz. It runs Windows Vista Home Premium on a 250GB 5400RPM hard drive with 2GB of RAM. Graphics are handled by an onboard nVidia GeForce 8600M GS with 256MB of memory. The Y510-300 isn't a slouch in the audio department, with four speakers and an embedded sub-woofer (2x 2 Watt speaker with chamber, 2x 1 Watt secondary speakers and 1x 2.5 Watt sub woofer). Networking connectivity is via 10/100 Ethernet, Intel PRO/Wireless 3945AGN (so it's a badged Centrino model), V92 Modem and Bluetooth.
The IdeaPad also comes with a 1.3 megapixel web camera, which in the current consumer market isn't anything special to speak of. What Lenovo has done with the Web camera is special, however; they've integrated it into the notebook's security system using an application called VeriFace. This lets you log into Windows, encrypt files and store passwords using a simple facial recognition system. On the consumer "cool" side, when it's scanning your face, it runs some totally superfluous-but-funky scan lines over the displayed screen, which is sure to bring a few "oohs" from anyone passing by when you're first logging in.
Lenovo offers a standard one-year warranty on the IdeaPad Y510 with 24/7 phone support and courier pickup and return during that period. Extended warranties are available at additional cost.
Performance
The nice factor about the IdeaPad picking up design cues from the ThinkPad range is that ThinkPads have long had great keyboards and a lot of sturdiness and this follows through on the IdeaPad when you're using it for practical work. It's easy to type on, the screen is clear and mostly glare-free and the touchpad has both good positioning and decent response. Fans of the Trackpoint "nipple", however, will no doubt be disappointed by its absence.
From a specifications point of view, we were looking for good things from the IdeaPad and it delivered nicely. With a PC Mark 05 score of 6127 and a 3D Mark score of 4355, this a capable machine for any consumer task. Our DVD battery rundown test was less inspiring, offering only one hour and twenty eight minutes running a full screen brightness DVD with all power saving measures disabled.
We were wary of how well VeriFace would work in practical terms, but came away very impressed; it logged us in seamlessly each time, even when sitting on angles. It rejected a photo of us -- we weren't quite willing to be decapitated to see if a skull would work -- and in a nice nod to security, it also logged failed attempts by other people to access our system. It should be noted that at least for Windows Vista Login, the VeriFace system is just an option; if somebody knows your system password they can still get access.
Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!
cromulentgreen
05/07/2008, 09:04 PM
rating
8/10
Picked it up for a steal - the basic Y510-100 for $897 at Domayne. Decent size screen & keyboard, and I love the textured cover. It's not my dream laptop, but with a 3 year warranty, bag, wireless mouse and usb stick for under $1,200... I think I made a great choice.
Pros: - cheap!
- elegant yet simple design
- cheap!
- decent size display & keyboard
- cheap!
Cons: - 5400 rpm HDD
- no bluetooth!
- underpowered processor for vista (1.6GHz)
- really annoying semi-gloss screen that leaves smudges too easily
- battery life doesn't seem that fantastic
Report offensive comment
Phil
15/06/2008, 11:32 AM
rating
2/10
This laptop is extremely disappointing. I have had one for only 3 months and it has given me no end of trouble. On start up, it typically powers down half way through the boot process. I can only get it to start properly around 3 times in 10. When it does start, it occasionally just shuts down, for no apparent reason, when I’m working. Its latest crash corrupted the file system, resulting in me having to do a full system recovery.
I know another person who has one of these and they report the network port is dead. I have no faith in this product. Seriously, if you don’t mind random crashes and the associated, loss of data then go ahead and get one but I wouldn’t advise it.
Pros: Nothing over and above other laptops in this price range
Cons: Unreliable. Very poor quality and performance for the price you pay
Report offensive comment
jimmy_sissi
21/04/2008, 02:45 AM
rating
8/10
nice..
cant say more...
Pros: as usual, good quality
Cons: as usual, expensive
Report offensive comment