Palm versus Pocket PC: Which is better?

By Rick Broida, CNET.com on 26 July 2004

Tags: 2003 | mobile | palm | palmone | pc | pda | pocket | review | vs | windows

PDA prize fight

Palm is the reigning champ of PDA OSs, but Windows Mobile 2003 is gaining ground fast. Which PDA operating system packs the biggest punch?

Microsoft may rule the desktop world, but in the battle for handheld supremacy, it's still anybody's game. Found in handhelds from PalmOne, Sony, and other manufacturers, the Palm operating system has held a market-share advantage since the beginning, but Windows Mobile 2003 (née Pocket PC) is no longer just nipping at its heels; it's nipping away at its sales, as well. But if you put the Palm OS in the ring with Windows Mobile, which PDA operating system would survive the bout? Is one notably stronger than the other?

To find out, we booked eight rounds of PDA pugilism, pitting Palm OS 5.2.1 against fast-rising challenger Microsoft Windows Mobile 2003 in categories such as ease of use, Office compatibility, and multimedia features. For the most part, we left the hardware outside the ring, as features such as battery life and processor speed vary widely from model to model across both platforms. The operating systems threw some seriously powerful jabs, and the winner may surprise you.

Go to the rounds:
Round 1: Ease of use
Round 5: Email
Round 2: Entering data
Round 6: Office compatibility
Round 3: Core applications
Round 7: Multimedia
Round 4: Desktop compatibility
Round 8: Available software

Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

someone
12/08/2004 07:02 PM

I thought u said you were going to leave hardware out of it??? Frequent referrals to the Zire 21, which is the lowest end OS5 PDA running, and you compared it to a mid range PocketPC system.

Report offensive content

Peta Kenchington
04/10/2004 12:07 PM

Have just purchased a second hand Tungsten E, with no software, cables etc. Used my orginal Zire software, a bought mult-charger [set correctly], the Zire Hot Syn cable, and voila, up and running in 3 mins: flat. Found the Graffit2 easy, not difficult to migrate from the G1 on the Zire. In other words easy, easy to use and set up. Will purchase a CD to get the extras, and have already loaded some trial software to play around with. Have a PDA since the beginning of the beasts, have tried diary's occassionaly, but always gone back, started with an orginal Sharp, so appreciate the current ones. Will stick to Palm in the foreseeable future. Real old user. PK..

Report offensive content

RT
01/11/2004 11:50 AM

Why didn't you considerer the capabilities of windows pocket pc mobile?? The palm cannot be a phone... The windows mobile can... And the software?? I founded more that 30000 programs to pda... I'm sorry but you have to be more realistic.

Report offensive content

  • Leave a comment

All fields marked with * are required

What do you think

Your e-mail will not be displayed

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars.


  • Samsung INNOV8 in Photos

  • Best mobile phones for Father's Day

  • LG Prada II comes with a keyboard?

  • Nokia 8800 Carbon Arte aims for the big end of town

  • Oi!: Nokia to launch video downloads

  • Apple's MobileMe suffers more downtime

  • Hands-on with the Samsung INNOV8

  • Nokia Tube appears in The Dark Knight?

  • Report: iPhone Nano in time for Xmas

More articles »

Find the right mobile phone

Brand
  • Multiple options can be selected

    The Explain Series

    Recycle your old mobiles
    • ASUS A696

      ASUS A696

      This slimline, brushed metal phone-less PDA packs GPS and Bluetooth, but somehow manages to miss out on Windows Mobile 6.

    • Vodafone 1210

      Vodafone 1210

      Want a Blackberry, but can't stretch the business budget to afford one? Vodafone's 1210 might suit your needs, but you'll need to put up with a lot of compromises along the way.

    • ASUS P735

      ASUS P735

      A handheld with good features for the business user, but those who want the latest HSDPA and GPS options may have to look elsewhere.

    • Mio Digiwalker P350

      Mio Digiwalker P350

      Mio's Digiwalker P350 isn't a stunning PDA. It isn't a stunning GPS, either. It's still a good unit, however --- read our review to find out why.

    • O2 Xda Stealth

      O2 Xda Stealth

      O2's Xda Stealth looks a lot like a regular slider phone, until you flick it open and notice the Windows Mobile 5.0 operating system, push e-mail capabilities and built-in Wi-Fi support.

    More reviews »

    Membership benefits

    Manage and receive subscriptions

    Manage and receive subscriptions

    Choose to receive an e-mail update containing our best articles either daily, weekly or monthly. Sign up for a free CNET.com.au membership now!