Ditch the disc: A guide to online music in Australia

By Randolph Ramsay on 25 October 2005

Ditch the disc: Guide to on-line music in Australia

CDs are like so 1990s, man. If you're ready to ditch the disc and want to disco over to digital, then check out CNET.com.au's list of the major on-line music stores in Australia.

First and foremost, iIf you're an iPod owner, you've really only got one port of call for licensed music -- the official iTunes Music Store (which can be accessed through the iTunes software). The vast majority of Australian music download sites cater exclusively for players that support Windows Media Audio (WMA) music files - Apple's little silver and white boxes can only play songs bought from the official iTunes store, which was recently launched after much delay.

And if this is your first time buying music on-line, be aware that each song or album you buy will have some sort of digital rights management (DRM) encoded onto it that determines the ways you can use it (such as how many times you can burn it to CD, what types of portable players you can play it on, etc). Be sure to read the fine print for each site. The only exceptions are MP3.com.au and Sound Foundation, which have no real restrictions on usage.

Last updated: 1st November, 2005

	Apple iTunes Features	Creative Music Store Features	DestraMusic.com Features	MP3.com.au Features	MTV Music Features
No. of songs	1,000,000	300,000	500,000	70,000	150,000
Average price	AU$1.69/song, AU$16.99	AU$1.49/song, AU$15/album	AU$1.89/song, AU$18.95/album	Free	AU$2/song, AU$18.50/album
File format	Fairplay protected AAC	WMA	WMA	MP3	WMA
Requirements	iTunes software, Windows 2000 or XP for PC, or Mac OS X v10.2.8 or later for Mac	Windows 98 and above, Windows Media Player 7.1 and above	Windows 2000/XP/ME, Internet Explorer 6 or above, Windows Media Player 9 or above.	Any program that can play MP3 music files	Windows 98 SE or above, Internet Explorer 4 or above, Windows Media Player 7.1 or above, Optus Mobile account (with compatible Optus Zoo mobile)
Restrictions	Music purchased can be played on up to five PCs Single songs can be burnt to CD an unlimited number of times Playlists can be burned up to seven times Music purchased can be transferred on an unlimited number of iPods	You can burn the song up to three times onto a CD. You can copy the song to up to three compatible portable music players. Up to two reinstalls in the first year after purchase.	You can burn the song up to three times onto CD. You can transfer it an unlimited number of times to three portable music players that can play licensed WMA files. Up to four re-installs per year allowed.	None	You can burn the song up to two times onto a CD. You can copy the song to up to two compatible portable music players. Up to two reinstalls in the first year after purchase.
Compatible players	Any Apple iPods or Motorola's Rokr phone.	Creative portable music players.	Any that can play licensed WMA files. Click here for the full list.	Any that can play MP3 music files.	Any that can play licensed WMA files. Click here for the full list.

	Mulemusic Features	nineMSN HMV Features	Soundbuzz Features	Sound Foundation Features	Telstra BigPond Music Features
No. of songs	200,000	780,000	300,000	1000	500,000
Average price	AU$1.69/song, AU$16.60/album (Prices will vary depending on when the song was released.)	AU$1.49/song (Listening to a live stream of a song costs 5c)	AU$1.49/song, AU$15/album	AU$1.20/song	AU$1.49 for BigPond internet customers. For non-BigPond customers it's AU$1.89. Albums are average AU$18.50 for non members.
File format	WMA	WMA	WMA	MP3	WMA
Requirements	Windows 98 SE and above, Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 and above or Netscape Navigator 7.0 and above, Windows Media Player 9.0 recommended.	Windows 98 or above, Windows Media Player 7.0 or above, Internet Explorer 5.0 or above.	Windows 98 and above, Windows Media Player 7.1 and above.	Windows 98 and above, Windows Media Player 7.1 and above. Mac compatible	Windows 98 or above, Windows Media Player 9.0 or above, either Internet Explorer 4 and above or Netscape 6 and above.
Restrictions	You can burn the song up to three times onto a CD. You can copy the song an unlimited number of times to up to two portable music players. Up to two reinstalls in the first year after purchase.	Varies from record label to record label. Check Rights Information link beside each song/album for details.	You can burn the song up to three times onto a CD. You can copy the song to up to three compatible portable music players. Up to two reinstalls in the first year after purchase.	None	The computer you download the song licence to is the only one that can play the track. You can burn the song up to three times onto CD. You can copy the song an unlimited number of times to up to two portable music players. Up to two reinstalls in the first year after purchase.
Compatible players	Any that can play licensed WMA files. Click here for the full list.	Any that can play licensed WMA files. Click here for the full list.	Any that can play licensed WMA files. Click here for the full list.	Any that can play MP3 files.	Any that can play licensed WMA files. Click here for the full list.

Apple iTunes Music Store
iTunes is finally up and running in Australia, and features an impressive number of tracks from both local and international artists. The iTunes Music Store also sells music videos and short films from Pixar for AU$3.39, which can be used exclusively on video-capable iPods.

Creative Music Store
Creative's Music Store works in the same way as iTunes', in which it's a program that has been customised to be an on-line store. You can download the MediaSource software from Creative's site, or if you're buying a new player from Creative it should be bundled in. The Media Source software, which is basically a re-tooled Windows Media Player but with the Music Store and Creative Soundblaster compatibility built-in, is only compatible with Creative players.

DestraMusic.com
Destra Music's site, one of the first in Australia to offer paid music downloads, also powers the on-line music stores of several leading Australian retailers, including Leading Edge, JB Hi Fi, Sanity and more. For a full list of retailers, visit Destra's website. Destra is also the company behind the free site MP3.com.au. destramusic.com (another fully owned subsidiary of destra) was the first company in Australia to launch a legal digital music service in December 2003

MP3.com.au
Before you rush off to MP3.com.au thinking that you'll be able to download Britney's best for free, be aware that the site is a forum for mainly unsigned artists to have their music heard. Artists from around Australia (and some internationally) upload their songs as MP3 files on the site, which means that there are no digital rights management issues to get your head around. If you're on the look-out for new music and want to sample some new sounds, MP3.com.au is the site for you.

MTV Music (powered by Optus Zoo)
MTV Music is an unusual beast in that it allows you to purchase songs either through your PC or through your mobile (providing you're an Optus customer), with the bill being charged to your monthly Optus mobile account. The service also allows you to download true tones for your mobile.

Mulemusic
Mulemusic has been up and running since February last year, and has a stronger focus on alternative and indie artists than some of the other music download sites - although you can still find your Delta's and George Michael's there.

nineMSN Music
nineMSN's music download store (which is officially co-branded the nineMSN HMV store) doesn't have a blanket DRM policy, with a spokesperson saying the rights vary from label to label. Users can check what a particular song/album's DRM is by clicking on the Rights Information link which should be present beside each song listed at nineMSN.

Soundbuzz
Soundbuzz was founded in Singapore and has an Asia-wide focus, which means as well as all the usual Western artists you'll find a great selection of Cantonese, Mandarin and Indian music. Soundbuzz is also the tech powering other local music sites such as Telstra BigPond, Creative' Music Store and Optus' MTV Music.

Sound Foundation
Sound Foundation was launched in May this year as a showcase for independent artists. Unlike the other online music stores, Sound Foundation tracks all of your purchases and allows you to download your songs as many times as needed

Telstra BigPond Music
It pays to have a BigPond internet account if you're planning to use BigPond Music, as you get a substantial discount from what Joe Public has to pay. At 500,000 songs it's one of the most exhaustive song list in the country, and a BigPond spokesman says they're adding roughly 1000 new songs a week to the site.

What do you think of Australia's on-line music stores? Are the DRM limitations too restrictive? Let us know about your on-line music experiences by e-mailing cnet@cnet.com.au.

E-mail this
Print this
Share this...
- del.icio.us
- digg this
- Reddit
- Slashdot
- StumbleUpon

Join CNET Australia Free newsletters, post to forums and win prizes. Join now - it's free and easy!

Related links

Five music download services compared

If you're keen to boost your music collection without stepping away from the glow of your monitor, our quick guide to Australian download services will give you all the info you need.
I purchased songs legally from BigPond Music; why won't they play on my iPod?

I purchased songs legally from BigPond Music; why won't they play on my iPod?
Unwrapped: Tips and tricks for your new MP3 player

Were you lucky enough to get a shiny new Creative Zen or an iPod Nano for the holidays? Before you get your groove on, here are three things you should know about digital music.
iTunes: Just how random is random?

Think that song has appeared in your playlists just a few too many times? David Braue puts the randomness of Apple's song shuffling to the test -- and finds some surprising results.

User comments
Leave a comment

Bob Harper
06/05/2005 04:14 PM

I've downloaded from nine/msn and found it to be a pain in the butt. I've been charged twice for several downloads (though I was refunded after complaining) and charged once for a song I didn't download. My 3 biggest complaints (in no particular order) are: 1. On this page :http://sib1.od2.com/common/Framework.aspx?shid=04AC002E the following startling note is located One of the tracks in my Playlist has turned red and nothing seems to happen, I can't stream or download it, why is this? (back to top) Sometimes Record Labels ask us to remove products. The track may still appear in your search, but as the file is removed the track turns red to let you know it can't be played. This seems to suggest that their music manager software is checking my music library for unlicensed music. If they decide to remove a track from my library without my permission can they legally do that? 2. After spending a lot of time digging around their help section I came to the conclusion that I can only re-licence the tracks I've bought twice. In other words, if my hard drive crashed I would have to use one of my licensing opportunities. Seeing as though I usually reformat my hard drive every six to eight months that means within 2 years I would have to re-purchase all my music! Even for the casual computer user who buys a new computer every 4 years this is hardly a lifetime licence. Compare this to the Apple Itunes policy of being able to use your music on up to five computers ar a time. Apple allows you to remove the music from your old computer and transfer it to your new computer (or fresh system re-install) am unlimited number of times. 3. The Nine/msn site charges you to preview tracks you buy. Seeing that some songs come in 4 or 5 different versions this is really annoying. As an example I downloaded some tracks by Suzi Quatro that she apparently did with a different band for some weird legal reason. I feel ripped off because these tracks were absolute crap. As you can tell, I won't be dealing with this outfit again. I'm eagerly awaiting the opening of the Apple Itunes store, and look forward to dealing with them. Friends of mine in Canada are extremely pleased with them. After having lost eveything in a housefire 2 years ago I've decided that it's time to standardise my music collection in a digital format. I plan on spending $100 a month for the next 2 years- I won't be buying CDs from record shops!

Report offensive content

Zippibubbles
09/05/2005 10:05 PM

I had used Bigpond Music extensively for a while but in the end I got fed up with disruptions in downloads, licensing issues and on a few occasions the wrong song being downloaded. I now use mp3.com the music may be new and from unheard of artists but it is always changing and updating and I haven't had any issues with their downloads.

Report offensive content

ruby-doo
28/06/2005 09:26 PM

I've had no problems downloading from Soundbuzz and Big Pond, but have had absolutely no luck with the ninemsn site. It seems very clunky and hangs up constantly! Anyone else having similar problems?

Report offensive content

tiina
14/09/2005 02:01 PM

Are there any sites that let you download classical music... or am I just being hopeful?

Report offensive content

chestnut
10/10/2005 02:25 PM

Your Better off buying CD from a store. The limitation on CD burning does not take into account bad burns. I have purchased albums online that have DRM restricted burns, problem being when burn/s fail - I'm left with no CD copy (for car stereo etc)

Report offensive content

Aragond
26/10/2005 11:33 PM

I'm so shattered to learn iTunes is using AAC format. What happened to good ole MP3?

Report offensive content

leo l rolle
08/10/2007 05:30 AM

cool

Report offensive content

Greg
22/04/2008 07:43 PM

I'm using 3 mobile music store. It's expensive at $3 per track and it doesn't have some of the artists I want but so far so good. I download to my pc and then transfer to my nokia phone. I can also download directly to my phone. I am unaware of any restrictions on how many computers or mobile devices I can use. I have the tracks on my phone, desktop and laptop and so far no dramas. Two tracks I bought would not download as they were listed but no longer in the database but customer service refunded my money straight away. The music I buy is billed to my phone bill.

Report offensive content

Keir
14/05/2008 06:48 PM

They really are treating consumers like cash cows. When you buy a record or CD, what you are actually paying for is a copy of the music recorded on it. That copy belongs to you, and is yours to use as you wish. Why isn't the same principle applied to digital music files that we pay for?

Report offensive content

tarzy
19/06/2008 12:02 PM

i think this site is great

Report offensive content

Toni
23/06/2008 02:58 PM

I agree with Keir Once you have bought the digital music file it should be your to do with what you wish, as long as you have have paid for it. Can someone explain to me why the difference. When will the copywrite people get it sorted out.? At the moment the laws are all over the place.

Report offensive content