Ask the editors

The flash advantage

2005/01/13 12:51:01

Question

I just read that Apple has come out with a flash version of the iPod. But what advantages, if any, does flash have over a similar hard drive MP3 player?

It looks like the current batch of flash players can only hold small amounts of music. Is it even possible to make a flash drive the size of, say, the current 20GB hard drive from Apple?

-- Submitted by: Eric

Answer

Answer by:
CNET.com staff

Flash-based players are smaller and less prone to damage, thanks in part to solid-state memory, and therefore make perfect exercise or day-trip companions. While flash-based players cost much more per megabyte than a hard drive-based player does, their prices are still more approachable.

Flash-based players max out at 1GB, and for good reason: solid-state memory is expensive, and most consumers would prefer a similarly priced microdrive-type player with five times the capacity. By the way, you can store about 250 songs on a 1GB player--not a bad number for most.

Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

Be the first to comment on this article!

  • Leave a comment

All fields marked with * are required

What do you think

Your e-mail will not be displayed

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars.


  • Sony Walkman NWZ-S730F

  • Oi!: Cowon's Curves seek your Touch

  • Oi!: Archos debuts two 'internet media tablets'

  • How to convert video for the iPod

  • Is microSD the music medium of the future?

  • Step inside Sony's uchi, sorry, home

  • Oi!: Stealthy new 4GB iPod Nanos spotted on shelves

  • Apple iPod Nano (4th generation)

  • Metallica and the iPod are dumbing down music

More articles »

Find the right mp3 player

Brand
  • Multiple options can be selected

    • Sony Walkman NWZ-S730F

      Sony Walkman NWZ-S730F

      Available in 8GB and 16GB versions, these wafer-thin players have built-in noise-cancelling technology and a 2-inch, 320x240-pixel LCD.

    • Apple iPod Nano (4th generation)

      Apple iPod Nano (4th generation)

      Apple has set the Nano back on track with the thinnest, lightest design yet, and has features that are hard to ignore.

    • Apple iPod Touch (2nd generation)

      Apple iPod Touch (2nd generation)

      If you've been holding back, now is the time: the second-gen Touch is an excellent media player, and the addition of third-party apps extends the fun for everyone, no matter where your interests lie.

    • Samsung S2 Pebble

      Samsung S2 Pebble

      Have you tried squeezing blood out of a stone? How about music out of a pebble? The Samsung S2 Pebble is a screenless MP3 player with an LED just under the surface that blinks different colours as you listen to music.

    • Creative Zen X-Fi 16GB

      Creative Zen X-Fi 16GB

      The Creative Zen X-Fi is finally here, and while it fits in the pocket and sound quality is excellent, the iPod Touch is still a superior product.

    More reviews »

    Membership benefits

    Contact community members

    Contact community members

    Add friends or tech gurus to you contacts and send them messages. Sign up for a free CNET.com.au membership now!