Ask the editors

What is the difference between MTP, UMS and MSC MP3 players?

2007/04/20 17:32:01

Question

What is the difference between MTP, UMS and MSC compliant players? Can they be detected on Macs?



-- Submitted by: Daniel S

Answer

Answer by:
Ella Morton

UMS and MSC are the same thing. This type of player functions as a mass storage device, and will show up on your computer as an external drive (eg "E:\"), just like a USB key or portable hard drive. You drag and drop your music files -- an application such as Windows Media Player is not required in order to transfer songs. You can put your music into folders if you want to sort it by artist, and these folders will show upon your device. Otherwise, the songs will be listed alphabetically.

With MTP, you will often need to use a program like Media Player in order to transfer files. The format also allows for metadata (album covers, automatic organisation of songs by artist, title and album).

If you have a Mac (and don't want to delve into the world of iPods), you'll want to go for a UMS player, as these should show up as an external drive on your computer. MTP players tend not to be compatible without a third-party program and a lot of fiddling around, and even then it's not guaranteed.

Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

anonymous
28/05/2007 01:24 AM

Good explanation! Thank you.

Report offensive content

some other guy
17/11/2007 02:02 AM

since the original question refered to the compability to macs, the answer were very long and didnt leave a definete answer at all. ums players (iriver among others) are compatible with all types of operating systems and hardware that support usb ports. dont ever support ipods and such junk that use their own stupid formats and applications to transfer music or video to the device.

Report offensive content

Anonymous_
03/01/2008 02:12 AM

THX for this answer! I do not know what is MTP mode, before you give me this answer.

Report offensive content

hachis
04/01/2008 05:46 AM

Same question with linux - UMS and MSC will both just mount as another external drive?

Report offensive content

  • Leave a comment

All fields marked with * are required

What do you think

Your e-mail will not be displayed

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars.


  • Oi!: Melbourne's Chadstone gets an Apple Store

  • Apple patent application blends touch, voice, face

  • iPod Touch and Nano blueprints revealed?

  • Super Monkey Ball

  • Apple makes 9 September iPod event official

  • Top 5 iPod features you'll never see

  • Internet allowed in Sydney school exam

  • Samsung S2 Pebble

  • BigPond Music offers legal iPod downloads

More articles »

Find the right mp3 player

Brand

    • Multiple options can be selected

    The Explain Series

    Telstra Explains ADSL2+

    • Samsung S2 Pebble

      Samsung S2 Pebble

      Have you tried squeezing blood out of a stone? How about music out of a pebble? The Samsung S2 Pebble is a screenless MP3 player with an LED just under the surface that blinks different colours as you listen to music.

    • Creative Zen X-Fi 16GB

      Creative Zen X-Fi 16GB

      The Creative Zen X-Fi is finally here, and while it fits in the pocket and sound quality is excellent, the iPod Touch is still a superior product.

    • Sony NWZ-A728 Walkman (8GB)

      Sony NWZ-A728 Walkman (8GB)

      Sony's new batch of Walkmans looks lovely and we're happy to see the end of SonicStage, but the features are a little bland compared to competitors' models.

    • iRiver Lplayer (8GB)

      iRiver Lplayer (8GB)

      The iRiver Lplayer is a very likeable player with a decent feature set and an ideal choice for anyone seeking a small and simple MP3 player for music. The best reason to choose it is its small size and intuitive navigation system.

    • Tonium Pacemaker

      Tonium Pacemaker

      The Pacemaker is a pricey but addictive toy for beat mixers, and a good way to experiment with song combos without having to lug records and turntables around.

    More reviews »

    Membership benefits

    Manage and receive subscriptions

    Manage and receive subscriptions

    Choose to receive an e-mail update containing our best articles either daily, weekly or monthly. Sign up for a free CNET.com.au membership now!