Netgear ReadyNAS Duo

The ReadyNAS range is a perfect addition to a household that needs not just storage, but control over that storage. Now if only Netgear could do something about the price.


9.0
CNET Rating
4.5
User Rating

View more from Netgear »

About The Author

CNET Editor

Craig was sucked into the endless vortex of tech at an early age, only to be spat back out babbling things like "phase-locked-loop crystal oscillators!". Mostly this receives a pat on the head from the listener, followed closely by a question about what laptop they should buy.


Design
After the huge success of Netgear's ReadyNAS NV+, which came with four drive bays, Netgear has released a smaller, two-drive version for those who have more modest needs. Coming in the usual box shape, Netgear's ReadyNAS Duo also comes in the usual black. On each side is a double strip of perforated air vents, on the rear two USB ports and a gigabit Ethernet port, with the front featuring a USB port, a programmable backup button, drive indicator lights and a power button.

Opening up the perforated front door reveals two quick release, hot-swappable drive bays, and this is where the ReadyNAS Duo stores its two SATA drives. There are three SKUs on the market, available with either a 500GB (RND2150, AU$699 — our test unit), 750GB (RND2175, AU$869) or 1TB (RND2110, AU$949) hard drive, all three leaving the second bay empty. We'd prefer there was one sold without drives at all to keep the cost down, but it's not to be.

Features
This is where Netgear flattens and dominates everything else on the market. The ReadyNAS Duo is ridiculously well featured, and although the interface is loaded up with technical network terms, it is well thought out, easy to use, and in most circumstances it explains in clear and concise detail what each feature does. You'll still need to be technically minded to take the most advantage of it, but to the geek crowd, it approaches perfection.

The feature list is impressive: file sharing is offered over CIFS/SMB, NFS, FTP, AFP, HTTP, HTTPS or Rsync (with individual shares being able to use specific protocols); media streaming via Slimserver, iTunes, UPnP AV and Home Media Streaming (for networked DVD players) servers. It offers Bonjour and UPnP discovery services; auto-photo sharing to the internet; a USB print server including queue management; scheduled backups, even to off-site devices; shared USB drives, and auto copying of files from a USB drive to a specified folder (useful if you're hooking up a digital camera); drive spin down with a user definable idle time limit; a BitTorrent server, so you can download straight to your NAS without needing your computer on; user and group account control with permissions and share management; allows performance enhancements by disabling certain network features; supports UPS management and like all good NAS devices, will send you an email alert when something goes wrong. You can even schedule a timer for when the system powers up and down, if you're energy conscious.

Impressively, if that isn't enough for you there's also an extensible add-on system, and more features can be downloaded and added to the drive by visiting the appropriate Web page.

The Duo still has a few flaws though. Unlike the ReadyNAS NV+, it only supports Netgear's X-RAID technology. While X-RAID usually auto-sets up a second volume as a mirror and then subsequent volumes in a RAID 5-like manner — since there's only two disks here mirroring is your only option — which means your second drive will have to be the same size or larger than the first. While most would use this mode anyway (and it's certainly recommended for data security), it's a shame not to see RAID 0 or individual drive support.

There also seems to be no way to reinitialise or format a hard drive from the interface. You can certainly resync drives so everything is mirrored perfectly if you add a second hard drive, but the only way we could find it to force it to reinitialise a single disk was to remove the disk, place it on a different channel, pull the power, then plug it in and start it up again.

We also found we couldn't access the interface until at least one disk has been initialised, and so had to wait until the blue-lit power button stopped flashing, rather than being given a progress style meter through an interface. Finally, although it's only a small niggle, the fan is incredibly obnoxious at first boot, and then drops into a dull grind. While like a router the box can be happily stuffed in a quiet corner and forgotten about, we'd still prefer a quieter fan in case the box is kept within earshot.

Performance
Hooking into an Asus RX3141 gigabit router, we sustained write speeds to the ReadyNAS Duo from our test Desktop PC of 18.7MBps average over CIFS, and 17MBps read using our standard 1GB test file, a decent result.

The ReadyNAS range is a perfect addition to a household that needs not just storage, but control over that storage. While you could technically build an old Linux box for less that offers more flexibility, the ReadyNAS cuts out the hassle, still offers tons of options, is significantly smaller and comes with a three-year warranty. Now if only Netgear could do something about the price.

Previous Story

QNAP TS-109 Turbo Station

Internet & Networking
Next Story

Iomega StorCenter ix2 (1TB)


Add Your Review 15


* Below fields optional


Post comment as
Seppo
10
Rating
 

"Great device, does what it says it does"

Seppo posted a review   
Australia

The Good:Large storage capacity, low power consumption

The Bad:Since the firmware upgrades, nothing

Laughing at all the retards using WIFI then blaming the device for slow transfer speeds. Learn how to use technology before posting imo.

oxphatxo
3
Rating
 

oxphatxo posted a review   

The Good:Yes, very good - EXCEPT!

The Bad:Painfully slow wifi transfers

I AM YOUR HOMEWORK ABOUT THIS DEVICE!
Like one person here said, it's awesome all around. If you like watching paint dry. Don't even bother thinking you'll get lucky, you won't. Wireless speeds don't exceed 1-2 mega BYTES per second, if you're lucky. If you plan on using the device with a wired LAN connection, you will get 10-12 mega bytes per second transfer speeds. There is NOTHING you can do about this, go ahead, read all the forums and all the people who've tried to figure out the problem. It's just the device that has the problem. Bottom line, it works alright with LAN. It's pretty, it works, it's just got slow wifi speeds.

 

hrsutty posted a comment   

The Good:fully featured.reliable

The Bad:performance.

Bought this baby NAS to team up with Logitech Squeezebox Duet using the native ReadyNAS client for Squeezebox. Setup was easy enough but performance is woeful.Constant buffering problems even when wired directly. Squeezebox Readynas client software probably contributes to the lack of response.
Using READYNAS as an ITunes server there are no buffering problems.
As noted by others ther seems to be no patches or fixes to improve performance . File transfer via Airport wireless network far from impressive.
Cant complain about reliability or ease of setup , and recovery from a power glitch was slow but thorough. Probably will turn out a great backup device.

pointer2null
4
Rating
 

pointer2null posted a review   

The Good:Lots of features, good size for home use

The Bad:poor support, slow transfer speeds

Got this as a replacement for an iomega drive, and compare with the utter junk that is iomega it's a vast improvement. But, as other have said, there are serious compatability issues with Win vista and Win7 (very poor transfer speeds ~ 200kbps over a 1Gbps lan) and support leaves an awful lot to be desired.

 

Patel-zaandam posted a comment   

The Good:looks

The Bad:problems with window 7 connection

Works fine with XP end with my mediaplayer from freecom.

With windows7 only http acces.

called al lot with all kinds of bobs in india but the only anwser i get is mmm thats new ik will maken an ticket.

www.pazo.nl

jpp
1
Rating
 

jpp posted a review   

The Good:hardware

The Bad:compatibility

Doesn't work properly with Windows 7. This all over the ReadyNAS forums. My attempts to get customer support were met with abysmal apathy and a refusal to help.

 

acrmorris posted a comment   

Just bought this little device, so still tweaking it. I was very concerned when i read about connection speeds, but this is purely a Vista issue and nothing to do with the ReadyNas. I am getting more and more impressed with the capabilities of this NAS and couldn't be happier with it

 

PHOENIX4FUN posted a comment   

RAID 0 CONFIG SEE http://www.readynas.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=18495

IJM
4
Rating
 

IJM posted a review   

The Good:Loads of features

The Bad:So slow reading and writing files

I really want to like this device but it does everything EXCEPT perform at a decent speed. Every few months I search in vain to see if Netgear has released a patch to improve performance. I have spent hours in forums reading endless stories like mine, tweaking endless settings with little or no effect. The fastest I have managed to read/write a file is 2 Mbs. Usually it is under 500Kbs. That's just too slow if you have a lot of big files/photos to move around.

Verdict: Only buy this device if you enjoy watching paint dry.

NotSatisfied
3
Rating
 

NotSatisfied posted a review   

The Good:Hardware setup is straightforward, hard drives install easily. It appears to have great media serving and FTP capabilities. Not sure, can't get past setting it up.

The Bad:Setup is not intuitive, at all. Documentation is useless, and didn't provide guidance to common setup issues. Called support and spoke to "Bob" (yeah right) in India, who was NO help.

The first unit brought home was not accessible on our LAN out of the box, and after much fussing we gave up on it. There was an issue with the power plug anyway, all I had to do was 'touch' the power plug and it would power down. So that unit got exchanged.

The current unit has no power plug issues, but still wasn't accessible from the LAN. The documentation only assists you through the best case scenario, i.e. everything is already working. So the documentation was absolutely useless in my case. That was when we decided to try their customer support. Wait time wasn't bad, but "Bob" from India, as you can imagine, was NO help. He advised me they had a newer version of 'RAIDar' the software that I later found to be useless anyway. "Bob" did not wait for me to install the new software, and just advised me to install it and call back if there were still problems. Whatever... the software didn't solve anything, and was a complete waste of time, but it did let "Bob" hang up. Won't waste any more time with them!

I spent some time looking online from real people that own these, and read some forums. One suggested resetting to the factory settings, I tried that and was finally able to see the unit's web setup interface from my LAN. The unit currently appears to be working, however now it won't let us create any user groups, users, or shares.

Great... I'm thinking I should have gone with the D-Link.


Sponsored Links

User Reviews / Comments  Netgear ReadyNAS Duo

  • Seppo

    Seppo

    Rating10

    "Laughing at all the retards using WIFI then blaming the device for slow transfer speeds. Learn how to use technology before posting imo."

  • oxphatxo

    oxphatxo

    Rating3

    "I AM YOUR HOMEWORK ABOUT THIS DEVICE!
    Like one person here said, it's awesome all around. If you like watching paint dry. Don't even bother thinking you'll get lucky, you won't. Wireless spe..."

  • hrsutty

    hrsutty

    "Bought this baby NAS to team up with Logitech Squeezebox Duet using the native ReadyNAS client for Squeezebox. Setup was easy enough but performance is woeful.Constant buffering problems even when ..."

Recently Viewed Products