Netgear SC101 Storage Central

By Jon L. Jacobi, CNET.com on 18 October 2005

More than just a networked hard drive enclosure, the SC101 provides some very useful features at a low price, making it a compelling choice for shared storage.

User rating:3.1
  • Good: Easy to set up • Drive spanning • Private and shared volumes
  • Bad: Currently accessible from only Windows machines • Passive cooling could be a problem with faster hard drives
  • Specs: Network Attached Storage (NAS) • See more specifications
  • RRP: AU$229.00 • Where to buy? Check price listings

If you're looking for network-attached storage (NAS) but have been put off by the high price per gigabyte, Netgear's SC101 Storage Central may just be what you're looking for. An unpopulated box (no hard drives) with two easy-access plain ATA drive bays, the SC101 has SAN-like drive-spanning and volume-sharing features. And if you shop carefully for hard drives, the completed drive can be considerably cheaper than the prepopulated competition, such as the Buffalo TeraStation or the Iomega NAS 200d. For features and price per gigabyte, you'll have a hard time beating it.

Setting up the Netgear SC101 Storage Central is easy, though it might be a bit daunting for anyone who doesn't like to open up electronics devices. The first step is to install a hard drive into each of the SC101's two bays; you'll need two if you want RAID mirroring (data stored simultaneously to two drives for redundancy), but you can use just one as well. The front panel of the SC101 has a low-profile latch that is opened with a coin, sort of like a ceramic piggy bank. Open the latch, remove the front panel, and slide the ATA drives in sideways. You must jumper the drives as Cable Select (CS), attach the power connectors and the short IDE ribbon cables, then latch the unit back up. If you need help, the SC101 ships with an excellent setup sheet and user guide.

After you attach the power cord and run an Ethernet cable to your router, you'll need to install the Storage Central Management Utility software from the included CD on each computer you wish to have access to the SC101. The Netgear SC101 isn't accessed via an IP address like many NAS boxes, but the software is easy to use and guides you nicely through the drive configuration process. However, less technically inclined readers should go over the manual first, and everyone should have a plan for how to divvy up the storage space. The SC101 allows you to divide the storage space, as well as share it among individual users. For example, you can assign part of the SC101's total storage capacity to your upstairs computer for private use, assign another part to the computer in the home office, then share part of it across all of the machines in the house for multimedia use, file transfer, and so on. There's no power switch on the mini-toaster-size unit, so home users might want to hook it up to a power strip or another switchable power source for shutdown during nonaccess hours.

Once you're through assigning volumes, you'll see those parts of the SC101's storage that are visible to each machine as a normal drive letter, not a mapped network drive, as with many Web administrated NAS boxes. The SC101 also has a feature normally found only in storage-area networks (SANs): the ability to create volumes that span multiple SC101s. If you add another SC101 Storage Central unit, you can access them separately or allocate space from both units as if they were a single volume. Alas, though Netgear told us that it's developing Mac and Linux drivers, for now, the SC101 is for Windows XP, 2000, and 2003 Server machines only. For backup for users who don't already have a favourite backup program, Netgear bundles the box with Storage Sync Pro.

Because the Netgear SC101 Storage Central ships without drives and its performance depends heavily on the drives you choose, we're not inclined to make a big deal out of the SC101's lackluster performance in our informal tests. However, with the single Western Digital Caviar WD800 hard drive that Netgear provided for testing, the SC101 was the slowest home NAS box we've seen to date at writing a 400MB folder of mixed file types as well as a 1.9GB single image file to its platters (in nonmirrored mode, using a shared partition). The SC101 was more competitive reading data back to our test bed, besting both Western Digital's NetCenter and Buffalo's TeraStation by small margins with the 400MB folder, though it was still the slowest we've tested with the 1.9GB image file. Still, the SC101's low price and features make it a compelling option in the field of network storage.

The Netgear SC101 Storage Central comes with a one-year warranty. The company's Web site has a helpful user forum for presales and post-free-period support problems, as well as firmware upgrades and a PDF version of the user manual. You can also send e-mail to tech support from the Web site.

Topics: storage, netgear, hard, drive, sc101, central, shared

Comments (21)

  • DiverMike gave 2/10 on 01/11/2009 18:12

    • Good: Looks nice
    • Bad: Everything

    Biggest problems are:
    It won't wake up, which makes it pointless.
    The software seems to screw XPSP3 up completely.
    I echo everyone else's comments. These should be recalled and scrapped. DO NOT BUY ONE!

  • hippy gave a review on 18/06/2009 13:12

    • Good: not much
    • Bad: ****

    waste of money , should be tested

  • dissapointeduser gave 10/10 on 27/01/2009 20:31

    • Good: brand
    • Bad: Everthing about this product, no usb interface, can not swap hdds, terrible.

    Terrible product! Unusable, this is not a true NAS (reformats your drive to zfs system)

  • BushJ gave 2/10 on 24/03/2008 05:18

    • Good: Looks pretty; seemed like a good idea at the time
    • Bad: Unreliable and unuseable. Manufacturer should do a full product recall to save their reputation.

    Same as everyone else. Got system to work of a fashion with XP pcs on router. Bought Vista machine which refuses to access Sc101

  • Masum gave 2/10 on 14/02/2008 12:50

    • Good: The Brand (Netgear)
    • Bad: Everything about this product

    How shocking!!! What a product from NetGear!!! Until now I would buy a Netgear product with my eyes closed but after having experienced with this product I'd think 100 times and do an extensive research before I buy any Netgear product again.
    What’s the point of having a backup/storage drive if it continuously corrupts your data!! I’d rather throw this piece of crap away than selling it on Ebay to waste someone else’s money and time.

    I’ve to say that I’m equally disappointed with CNet’s review on this. Anybody reads this review will be under the impression that this is an ideal product for home users, which is not true at all. I thought we could trust on you guys!!!!! Come On!!! And where’s CNet’s rating on this?!?!

  • Kazmanic gave 2/10 on 17/01/2008 10:47

    • Good: Makes a good paper weight.
    • Bad: Takes a lot of stuffing about to setup, then does not work.

    Seemed to setup okay, but after I upgraded the software as recommended by Netgear it's disappeared as a drive in 'My Computer'. Now won't recognize admin password and help files display a runtime error. What a waste of money.

  • Tonebone gave 2/10 on 24/09/2007 23:27

    • Good: None
    • Bad: Doesn't work. Simply doesn't work

    Oh dear. I have the same problems. The support team are very friendly, but not very knowledgeable. I'm getting tired of the music on hold now fellas....

    This is a product that does not work.

    It's a shame - Net gear should give money back to anyone who bought this product if they want to get anyone to buy their product ever, ever again.

  • networkman gave 7/10 on 17/05/2007 21:05

    • Good: Very convenient and secure. Access can be granted on a user login basis. Small, quiet, and trouble-free.
    • Bad: Difficult to setup. Tech support is weak. MP3 player may cause reassignment of drive letter if computer goes into "standby".

    It took some figuring, but now works very well. To resolve unreliable connect issues, I wrote a .BAT file to start the Zetera service after everything else. Here is the content of the .BAT file:

    @echo off
    echo Please wait until the drive activity
    light is not glowing steady, then
    Pause
    @echo on
    Net Start Zetera
    Exit

    This allows the computer to settle down after startup before starting the network drive.

  • Neil gave 2/10 on 05/05/2007 20:57

    • Good: Nice footprint, efficient use of storage in a network.
    • Bad: It is way too unreliable to be recommendable. It is a *false economy*. I am looking at more expensive products as this is just a waste of time. Mine will be on eBay soon. Bid on it yourself if you dont believe me !

    I am an IT professional in a family of 4 people each with PCs on a home network. The SC101 seems an inexpensive way of sharing storage without having the overhead of leaving one machine on to work as a server. I like the principle of the SC101, but the execution falls way short of its promise. The reality is that it is unreliable and difficult to administer, the software is really unreliable. I have only been able to get the SC101 to work from one PC. The access time seems OK (on video!). It will attach within 15 seconds to a PC. But the PC I'm on is still hanging on after 30 minutes. "Why" I ask !! I've had to drop and reformat the drive once already and make a registry change on one PC to make the drive just *visible*. It uses proprietary disk access (ie not FAT or NFTS) and that just adds to the complexity of the thing.

  • John701 gave 3/10 on 16/03/2007 06:20

    • Good: small footprint, no noisy fan running all the time
    • Bad: No Windows Vista support. Drives formatted differently that standard IDE drives

    easy setup - NO WINDOWS VISTA Support. Now I must leave one of my PC's on XP until/if they update the driver.

Post your own

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 & A..F

Submit

Enter your personal information to the left, or sign in with your Facebook account by clicking the button below.

Connect

The Explain Series

Where to buy Netgear SC101 Storage Central

See all options »

Must read

Advanced search

Product finder

Recently viewed products