Nokia culpa: phony Lumia 920 video prompts ethics probe

A Nokia "ethics and compliance officer" is conducting an internal investigation to find out why the company published a misleading promotional video for its new 920 phone.

One of Nokia's first Lumia ads showed a couple shooting video with a Lumia 920, comparing it to video shot without Nokia's optical image stabilisation.
(Credit: Nokia)

Nokia committed a major gaffe in promoting its Lumia 920, and now the company has said that it's trying to figure out why.

Last week, the company unveiled its new Windows 8 Phone handsets, with the Lumia 920 starring as its flagship device. Touting the phone's optical image stabilisation (OIS), Nokia released a promotional clip supposedly comparing video shot by the 920 using OIS with video shot by a phone without OIS.

But after The Verge noticed an odd reflection in the clip, Nokia confessed that the OIS video was actually shot by a normal video camera, and not the 920. The company also admitted to using still images taken from that same faked video, and apologised for all the "confusion".

An ethics and compliance officer for the company is now investigating the matter "to understand what happened", a Nokia spokeswoman told Bloomberg.

In a mea culpa blog posted last Thursday, the company said that the video was produced to simulate what can be done with OIS. But it acknowledged that a disclaimer should have been included. Nokia also quickly posted a legitimate video comparing the 920's OIS with a phone without OIS.

A Nokia spokesman sent CNET the following statement:

Nokia recently apologised when it became clear that a video, which had been produced to demonstrate the benefits of optical image stabilisation, failed to make clear that it was a simulation only, and not shot using the new PureView camera on the Nokia Lumia 920. This video was produced while the Nokia Lumia 920 was in early prototype, and still not ready to show the full benefits of the amazing innovation it contains. While there was no intention to mislead, the failure to add a disclaimer to the video was obviously a mistake, and we apologise for the misunderstanding it did cause.

The bad publicity is likely to be short lived. But it does send a warning to Nokia, especially at a time when the company is struggling to make a dent in the competitive smartphone market.

The spokeswoman told Bloomberg that Nokia is dealing with the issue "quickly, fairly and privately". That sounds like someone at Nokia is going to have to take the rap for the snafu, if only to ensure that the company's products speak for themselves from now on.


Add Your Comment


Be the first to comment on this story!

Post comment as

Sponsored Links

Recently Viewed Products