Photos on the spot: four snapshot printers compared

By Rebecca Viksnins, CNET.com on 19 April 2005

Tags: canon | epson | hp | photo | printer | snapshot | sony | quality | yes | photosmart

Photos on the spot: four snapshot printers compared Why wait for stellar snapshots? One of these four portable snapshot printers will deliver quality 4x6 prints on the spot, and several of these printers come with convenient photo-oriented features, such as media slots and PictBridge support. Read on to find out how they compare.

No matter how invested you are in the myth of the paperless digital culture, you have to admit that it's still cool to have a copy of a prized shot in your hands only minutes after you've snapped it. Nowadays, it's possible to crank out a great 4x6 photo from just about anywhere, thanks to the portable snapshot printer.

Designed strictly for on-the-spot photo printing, portable snapshot printers come in two flavours. One type uses thermal dye-transfer technology (also known as dye sublimation) in which heat changes the physical state of solid inks until they infuse specially coated paper, solidifying as they cool. The second type uses six-colour inkjet technology, adding light cyan and magenta to the usual cyan, magenta, yellow and black. Both types typically come with convenient photo-related extras, such as an LCD for previewing and selecting images, digital media card slots, and ports that allow for direct printing from supported cameras or external storage devices. Some portable printers come with a rechargeable battery or car chargers, though truly mobile printing is typically accompanied by a premium price.

We rounded up four snapshot printers from leading vendors, put them through their paces, and rated them on their design, features, speed, print quality and quality of their tech support. Though the Sony DPP-EX50 appears to have the best print quality, its prints don't last very long -- a mere four years, according to Wilhelm Imaging's tests -- and they suffer the worst metamerism, colour shifts under different light sources. So, all things considered, the Epson PictureMate's vibrant, accurate, long-lived prints take top honors. But print quality aside, there's no clear Editors' Choice winner in the group. Each one of these printers has pros and cons; the one you choose has everything to do with your needs. The economical Epson PictureMate cranks out quality prints, but it's slow, and if you're a photographer on the go, you'll wish it came with a battery pack. The Canon DS-700 wowed us with its stylish design, but it's expensive and lacks battery-powered operation, which could be a deal breaker for some.

Photo printer performance (Shorter bars indicate better performance)
Minutes per photo  

To help you figure out which snapshot picture might be right for you, we've put together this chart detailing each printer's features. And as always, we encourage you to read the full reviews for the whole story.

Printer Canon Selphy DS-700
Canon Selphy
DS-700
Epson PictureMate
Epson PictureMate
HP Photosmart 375
HP Photosmart 375
Sony DPP-EX50
Sony DPP-EX50
Power supply options AC only AC only Rechargeable battery option (Photosmart 375B) AC only
Media slots Flash I and II, Secure Digital/ MultiMedia, SmartMedia, Sony Memory Stick, and xD None CompactFlash I and II, Microdrive, SmartMedia, Sony Memory Stick, Secure Digital/ MultiMedia, and xD; optional Bluetooth adapter Compact-
Flash I and II, Memory Stick
LCD None None 2.5-inch, colour LCD 1.5-inch LCD
PictBridge compatible Yes; also supports printing from mobile phones via IR Yes Yes Yes
Weight 1.8 kg 1.3 kg 1.2 kg 3.4 kg
Summary It's stylish and ultraportable, but this Canon is missing some key photo-related features. This Epson produces excellent prints, but to do so, it sacrifices speed. This HP is packed with features, but the print quality isn't all it could be. This quirky photo printer is meant to work alongside your wide-screen TV, but its design won't appeal to everyone.

Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

Lorna Powell
29/06/2005 09:13 PM

I purchased the Epson Picturemate some time ago. It does take quite some time to produce the photos but I have been very pleased with the results. It is very easy to use even during the first print it guides the user by very explicit straightforward instructions. The colour is superb and will last a lifetime. There now a new model Picturemate 500 (released about 24.6.05) which has a screen to preview photo shots and an optional battery for extra use. However my Picturemate is a very good all round printer without any hassles. I am pleased I purchased it.

Report offensive content

  • Leave a comment

All fields marked with * are required

What do you think

Your e-mail will not be displayed

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars.


  • Canon Selphy CP770

  • Oi!: Turn your photos into a movie

  • Canon Pixma iP100 Inkjet Printer

  • Polaroid debuts pocket-size photo printer

  • Photos: Annoying hardware, a rogues' gallery

  • Printer's gel-like ink works on everything

  • Best printers for homes on a budget

  • Canon Selphy ES2

  • New way to save energy: Disappearing ink

More articles »

Find the right printer

Brand
  • Multiple options can be selected

    • Canon Selphy CP770

      Canon Selphy CP770

      The Canon Selphy CP770 is a neat, little dye-sublimation printer that includes a bucket for easy travel, but the battery pack which would make it totally portable is not included.

    • Canon Pixma iP100 Inkjet Printer

      Canon Pixma iP100 Inkjet Printer

      It isn't cheap compared to standard printers, but the Canon Pixma iP100 has the highest resolution available in the mobile printer market and prints at an impressive speed to boot. If you simply must have a printer with you at all times, the iP100 should be the do-it-all at your side.

    • Canon Selphy ES2

      Canon Selphy ES2

      Although it offers no technical upgrades from its predecessor, an enhanced user interface and larger LCD display improve on the impressive ES1, making the Canon Selphy ES2 a pleasing choice for a dye-sub photo printer.

    • Epson Stylus Photo R1900

      Epson Stylus Photo R1900

      Epson's Stylus Photo R1900 photo printer is great for scrapbookers who want to print with pigment ink or advanced photographers who want to print large but can't justify the expense of a pro-level printer.

    • HP Photosmart A626

      HP Photosmart A626

      The HP Photosmart A626 is supposed to bridge the gap between the A826 and the A526 snapshot printers by providing lots of features, good print quality, and decent print speeds, but it falls short on the last two counts.

    More reviews »

    Membership benefits

    Create a personalised homepage

    Create a personalised homepage

    Choose your interests from our 16 categories and only see articles relevant to you. Sign up for a free CNET.com.au membership now!