Apple Aperture

By Theano Nikitas, CNET.com on 16/03/2006

More Apple reviews , RRP: AU$699.00

The good:

  • Excellent sorting and organising tools
  • Very fast on the right hardware
  • Smooth work flow from one task to another
  • Attractive interface

The bad:

  • Requires high-end system for optimal results
  • Closed architecture
  • All images stored in single, monolithic library
  • Subpar interaction with other applications

The bottomline:

This imaging work-flow application isn't the Holy Grail many hoped it would be, but Apple Aperture could make life easier for photographers who need to sort through large numbers of photographs quickly and efficiently.

Buying choices:

Users' rating:

10/10

Until introducing Aperture, Apple's only photography application was the consumer-friendly iPhoto. With Aperture, Apple squarely targets pro and prosumer digital photographers who need a work-flow tool for quickly sorting, editing, managing, and outputting lots of images. Designed to address multiple needs, Aperture's feature set provides sorting and culling capabilities as well as digital asset management, image editing, and several output options. Overall, Aperture does a decent job, although it falls short in some areas and excels in others.

Aperture lives up to many of its promises and proves especially useful as a digital slide sorter -- albeit an extremely pricey one -- but there's room for improvement, especially when it comes to image adjustments as well as handling of raw files and metadata. For instance, we'd like to see curve editing in addition to levels. And though Aperture supports nondestructive raw editing, in order to open the files in Photoshop, you have to export them to the desktop or a folder first. If you create any Photoshop layers, Aperture will simply store the layered file in the Library and create a flattened version for itself. For that and other reasons, we think Adobe Camera Raw still has an edge over Aperture for working with raw files.


Take our guided tour of Apple Aperture.

The Library secrets away all your images from view into an operating system package file, a file type usually reserved for installation programs. This likely renders your images slightly more vulnerable, in an all-eggs-in-one-basket kind of way. You can create a replica of the Library called a Vault for backup purposes. Maintaining a backup is one-click simple, however.

Aperture can be an incredibly fast and efficient application, given the right system. With few exceptions, the "right system" turned out to be a quad G5 with 2GB of RAM; importing and adjusting images on this system zipped along. Occasionally, drawing the Loupe tool across images in the thumbnail view required a couple of seconds' wait. On a 15-inch G4 PowerBook with 2GB of RAM, waiting a second or two to load a file while using the Loupe became more frequent, and stacking images was noticeably slower. Using Aperture on the 15-inch G4 PowerBook (the 12-inch model's graphics subsystem isn't powerful enough) is doable, but professionals will want to have a fast desktop system in the studio. Furthermore, Aperture is best viewed on at least one 30-inch Cinema Display: Aperture's icons and typeface can be very small and difficult to read.

Open the Aperture box and you'll find a Getting Started Guide, which will get you up and running, but it won't tell you about some of the application's finer points. The better option is to watch the video that's bundled with the software. Apple has posted a lot of information on its Web site, including tutorials and FAQs, but searching from within the program doesn't always result in a quick answer to your question. There aren't many live support options, other than Apple's typical free 90-day installation support for registered users.

There are at least three potential roadblocks to adopting Apple Aperture: steep hardware requirements, rigid file handling, and dependence on the OS for raw support. But despite these limitations and imperfections, Aperture can certainly bring efficiency into the life of any photographer willing to accede to the program's demands.

Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

stingerman
17/03/2006, 06:34 AM

Package type is a folder, Raw updates

Just to fix an inaccuracy. Packages are a special type of folder. You can actually view it's hiererachal contents, when you right click and select Show Package contents. So this isn't in any way a monolithic file. It's just a way for Apple to keep the folders and files together and neatly organized.

Aperture relies on the RAW capabilities of OS X Tiger (10.4). So make sure you stay current (today it's at 10.4.5). Apple has been regularly been adding new RAW formats and improving their current RAW processing with each point upgrade, without having to upgrade Aperture. So your RAW experience will vary depending on the version of 10.4 you are at, make sure to stay current.

Report offensive comment

  • Leave a comment

All fields marked with * are required

What do you think

Rate this product:

Need help? Read our guidelines for what each number rating represents.

Your e-mail will not be displayed

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars.

  • Google adds Android app for Flickr photos

  • Revamped Google Picasa site identifies photo faces

  • Adobe releases Photoshop and Premiere Elements 7

  • Microsoft site makes digital photos into panoramas

  • Get the most out of iPhoto 08

  • Adobe hopes Lightroom captures photo trends

  • MobileMe

  • Memeo launches Share for sending photos to grandma

  • Free Speed: Make your Mac faster

More articles »

Find the right software

Brand
  • Multiple options can be selected

    The Explain Series

    • MobileMe

      MobileMe

      MobileMe is the successor to .Mac, Apple's subscription service for publishing photos and other personal content to the Web.

    • Adobe Photoshop Express Beta

      Adobe Photoshop Express Beta

      Though there's a lot to like about Adobe's first stab at online photo editing and sharing, you probably want to wait until the company fixes a few problems with the beta — and defangs its terms of service — before uploading scads of photos to Adobe Photoshop Express.

    • Reallusion CrazyTalk 5

      Reallusion CrazyTalk 5

      The latest version of facial animation program Crazy Talk is still freaking us out — in a good way.

    • Apple iLife '08

      Apple iLife '08

      Apple iLife '08 is a fine, affordable media-editing suite that should keep beginners and hobbyists happy when managing pictures, videos, songs and podcasts, but those seeking to fine-tune movies should look elsewhere.

    • Adobe Creative Suite 3 Production Premium

      Adobe Creative Suite 3 Production Premium

      Adobe CS3 Production Premium is ideal if you handle a mix of design, animation and editing tasks for video, the Web, and mobile gadgets.

    More reviews »

    Membership benefits

    Win prizes and other promotion benefits

    Win prizes and other promotion benefits

    As a CNET.com.au member, you're eligible to enter and win any prizes on our site. Sign up for a free CNET.com.au membership now!