Join CNET.com.au: Receive free newsletters, post to forums and win prizes. Sign up now!

Whaddyareckon?: MySpace vs. Facebook

By Ella Morton on 06 July 2007

Tags: facebook | myspace | whaddyareckon

Get Adobe Flash player

Though its image is tarnished by the presence of bulletin spam, tales of hacked accounts and glittery graphics that cause permanent corneal trauma, MySpace continues to reign supreme when it comes to sheer number of visitors.

Stats released by Nielsen//NetRatings this week show that 2.75 million Australians -- or one in five Internet users -- visited the site in May 2007.

The Murdoch-owned mega site may still be pulling in the punters, but another contender for the social network crown has enjoyed a stratospheric rise of late: Facebook. In six months, Facebook has gone from attracting 31,000 unique visitors per month to 287,000 (as measured by Nielsen//NetRatings from November 2006 to May 2007).

Sure, this may be one-tenth the size of MySpace's audience, but the swiftness of Facebook's ascension is still remarkable. With its news feed, cleaner layouts and profile-viewing restrictions (you need to be on the same location-, school- or work-based network as someone else to see their page), Facebook has carved out a niche as a more grown-up, refined version of MySpace.

So will MySpace crash and burn as its followers de-friend the ubiquitous Tom and flock to Facebook? Or does the social networking behemoth have staying power beyond its novelty value? We hit the streets and asked people if they're sticking with MySpace.

If you've bailed on MySpace and fallen into the comforting indigo embrace of Facebook, check out our Whaddyareckon? Facebook group, where you can suggest topics for future shows.

blindslide
06/07/2007 01:55 PM

Hehehe, first! I've definitely made the jump into the 'book. It is much more simple and eaiser to navigate than the 'space, especially nowadays when a myspacer's idea of graphically pleasing design is so often thrown out the window. The 'book also allows you to minimise the sections of info/apps that you aren't interested in, so you don't have to put up with someone's crappy flash movie of themselves doing something inane. And did I mention the 'book is simpler to navigate and easier on the eye? It's the beginning of the end, 'spacers!

Report offensive content

man.dovvn
08/07/2007 05:52 PM

FB is offering applications now to embed videos and music. As long as there's an option to block these from loading when browsing, FB will be king.

Report offensive content

DChapman
DChapman
09/07/2007 08:07 AM

MySpace is terminally ugly, difficult to use and hard to navigate. Facebook is the opposite hence Facebook wins!

Report offensive content

Himeno
10/07/2007 04:46 AM

Niether. Both those sites are massive wastes of bandwidth

Report offensive content

PM
16/07/2007 04:57 PM

Is the guy that talks most during that interview the 'Free hugs' guy??

Report offensive content

Ella Morton
Ella Morton
17/07/2007 11:00 AM

Yep, it's Juan Mann, pioneer of the Free Hugs movement. For the MySpacers: http://www.myspace.com/freehugscampaign And for the Facebookers: Campaign For Free Hugs group http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=2211771066

Report offensive content

tasharra
01/08/2007 10:29 AM

I think facebook iz better

Report offensive content

  • Leave a comment

All fields marked with * are required

What do you think

Your e-mail will not be displayed

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars.


  • News

  • Features

  • Oi!

  • Must read

  • Memeo launches Share for sending photos to grandma

  • Do browsers need a 'best-before' date?

  • Free Speed: Make your Mac faster

  • Yahoo Go! hits 3.0

  • Powerhouse adds photos to Flickr Commons

  • New geotagging method draws on Flickr photos

  • Firefox 3: New front in the browser war

  • Bring thumbnails to life with SnapCasa

  • IE7Pro

More news »

Find the right software

Brand
  • Multiple options can be selected

    • Firefox 3

      Firefox 3

      If only for the speed, lightness of being and security alone, Firefox remains our Editors' Choice for best internet browser.

    • Opera 9.5

      Opera 9.5

      Long considered a cult favourite, Opera 9.5 for Windows and Mac has introduced some compelling improvements to security, speed and synchronisation — yes, syncing in a browser!— is there enough here to make you a convert?

    • Nokia Music Store

      Nokia Music Store

      If you can access the Nokia Music Store then we think it's worth a look; but Nokia isn't making it easy.

    • Adobe Media Player 1.0

      Adobe Media Player 1.0

      Adobe's Media Player is an excellent application that is beautifully designed and easy to use. Shame about the currently available content.

    • Adobe Photoshop Express Beta

      Adobe Photoshop Express Beta

      Though there's a lot to like about Adobe's first stab at online photo editing and sharing, you probably want to wait until the company fixes a few problems with the beta — and defangs its terms of service — before uploading scads of photos to Adobe Photoshop Express.

    More reviews »

    Membership benefits

    Create a personalised homepage

    Create a personalised homepage

    Choose your interests from our 16 categories and only see articles relevant to you. Sign up for a free CNET.com.au membership now!