Sony HDR-HC3 HDV camcorder

By Nicole Manktelow, CNET.com.au on 04 July 2006

A good choice for families wanting to match a camera to their HD TV set. Automatic operation means not needing to know much to get pleasing images. More advanced videographers may be a little frustrated by the manual controls.

8.0 7.1
  • Good: Great image in either SD or HD • Quick response to changing scene • Some image control provided by auto/manual toggle and dial • Touchscreen LCD has additional recording controls
  • Bad: Camera controls most image settings • No external battery charger
  • Specs: MiniDV (HDV), Memory Stick Duo, Memory Stick PRO Duo, High Speed Memory Stick PRO Duo • See more specifications
  • RRP: AU$2,299.00

Anyone who has already shelled out for a high definition TV set, or is thinking of doing so in the next 12 months will, no doubt, be intrigued by HDV camcorders. If there's nothing broadcast in HD on telly, they can at least watch the kids' footy match in all its muddy glory.

Loosely translated, the 1080i standard means images are recorded at 1080 lines of resolution. No surprises then, that high definition cameras provide a new level of detail and clarity, but while it may be possible to enhance beautiful images, the same might be said of images recorded by inexpert hands and every little mistake they make. So, of course, delivering high def' capabilities to consumers is not just a matter of sticking the right chip in a camera. It's in the manufacturer's interest make the resulting images look as good as possible, whether or not the person at the controls knows what they're doing.

Enter Sony's HDR-HC3 -- described as an "ultra compact" camcorder. It is perhaps the most consumer-oriented model so far, within the HDV range pioneered by Sony. All members of the range can generally be commended for their automatic features, but this camcorder really depends on them.

If default settings for automatic were not enough for the timid cameraperson, there's Easy mode (perhaps better described as "even easier" mode). Pressing the Easy button takes what is essentially the standard automatic operation just a little further by disabling a few other settings. Perhaps its main purpose is to be of reassurance for those consumers who fear accidentally selecting a setting they don't understand.

Anyone looking to manually control the settings, such as those defining exposure -- shutter speed, iris or gain -- will be frustrated that these are controlled by the camera and that they get only a single exposure setting (but they probably shouldn't be looking at products at this end of the market anyway, albeit in an HDV camera).

Anyone who is happy enough to let the camera do the work should be pleasantly surprised with the outcome. The automatic features tend to get it right and they're quicker than one might expect. For example, if moving quickly from one subject to another in moderate light levels, the camera refocuses very quickly and smoothly to cope with changes.

For those who haven't made the leap to HD, take heart. The camera automatically down converts to the usual DV format for standard definition TVs and VCRs and the resulting image quality, whilst standard definition, is still rich and clear.

Of course, a Carl Zeiss lens helps achieve quality images, for either video or still. The HDR-HC3 also offers 4-megapixel stills, but stored only on Sony's own MemoryStick Duo or Duo Pro. Video is recorded to MiniDV tape. (While there are special HDV tapes available, professionals using HDV cameras use standard MiniDV tapes).

As one might expect from a camera touting high definition abilities, the bright, wide touchscreen LCD is one of its best features. It also has a secondary zoom control and recording start/stop which, by enticing two-handed operation, tends to help the user steady the camera and hold it more comfortably.

The touch screen is also how you control most of the settings. Poking your way through the menu system does give some image control to the user, but it's generally too clumsy if in a hurry or trying to capture a natural moment. Trying to set the manual focus or exposure, for example, in this manner is tedious.

As a concession, Sony has provided an easy to reach auto/manual toggle and dial near the lens. It offers access to one setting at a time, so you could leave it set on exposure or manual focus for ease. Or, one can also cycle through these by pressing and holding the manual button. (Without this feature users would be forced to go painfully through the touch screen menu each time they wanted to adjust more than one aspect of an image.)

There are a few minor quibbles with this camera: for starters, users have to charge the battery on the camera itself, so you can't use the camera and charge any extra batteries without buying a separate charger.

This camera also tried to make a bit of a fashion statement with a pleasing dark grey metallic and black casing, but the old fashioned battleship grey battery is the equivalent of a VPL (visible panty line).

The connectors available for this camera are an important part of the high definition equation. The camera has an HDMI (High Definition Multimedia Interface) port to connect to TVs with HDMI inputs. To use a firewire cable to connect to a TV you need one with a jack compatible with HDV 1080i.

Sony's copy protection mechanisms add a level of complexity. Presumably these will only affect would-be pirates, but it's worth being aware of limitations when troubleshooting in general. The HDMI connection won't work for output if the camera detects copy control signals in the images. And, the camera won't output images that are input to the camera with firewire.

Topics: sony, video camera, hdr-hc3, camcorder, hdv, camera, image, setting

Comments (13)

  • John gave a review on 02/06/2009 09:52 Report abuse

    If you get this to do HD video capturing and editing on a PC...you will be EXTREMELY frustrated. After a week of trying to find a solution, (Sony tells me to talk to my Capture software company I'm using..and the software companies tell me to talk to Sony!!) I was finally able to capture the HD 1440X1080i format with HDVsplit...they will play on windows media player if you rename the extension to mpg, but are worthless to any video editing program on a PC.

    • Good: Good camera all around
    • Bad: Horrible for capturing and editing on a PC in HD
  • John gave a review on 02/06/2009 04:24 Report abuse

    If you get this to do HD video capturing and editing on a PC...you will be EXTREMELY frustrated. After a week of trying to find a solution, (Sony tells me to talk to my Capture software company I'm using..and the software companies tell me to talk to Sony!!) I was finally able to capture the HD 1440X1080i format with HDVsplit...they will play on windows media player if you rename the extension to mpg, but are worthless to any video editing program on a PC.

    • Good: Good camera all around
    • Bad: Horrible for capturing and editing on a PC in HD
  • roadkillcollector gave 10/10 on 20/10/2007 07:44 Report abuse

    Excellent video quality.

    • Bad: no manual shutter speed control, but no biggie.
  • jack gave 2/10 on 29/07/2007 22:20 Report abuse

    get a vx2000

  • RP gave 3/10 on 20/07/2007 14:44 Report abuse

    Sony is pretty much ripping you off on this one. I did "educate" myself prior to purchasing the camera this past December. I purchased the optional DVD recorder that Sony sells with the bundled Nero editing soft ware. Well, the basic Nero wouldn't recognize the format and so I couldn't edit any of my movies. I also can't burn any more copies of the DVD I made as my computer doen't recognize the format either.

    • Good: Light weight, easy to use. Picture looks good on a HD monitor, using the camera as your tape player.
    • Bad: No support, bundled software, supporting hardware is limited.
  • NeK gave 7/10 on 17/06/2007 11:20 Report abuse

    Well Nothing wrong with the camara it self. But for editing your HDV I use Pinnacle software and after spending like 4 hours with Transestions and menus. I went to Make Movie and it was going to take over 24Hours to convert into ture HD?????

    • Good: Great cam corder and easy to use it on your HD-TV.
    • Bad: No editing software or support for editing your final HDV
  • nikolas9 gave 9/10 on 09/06/2007 19:21 Report abuse

    lost the manual!!!!.where can I buy another one????

    • Good: versatile
    • Bad: too many functions
  • pwanda gave 9/10 on 12/11/2006 12:32 Report abuse

    I don't think it is fair to criticise the HDR-HC3 for its lack of bundled extras. Sure, the inclusion of an iLink cable would've been nice... but I got mine for $12.. no big deal.

    If you are going to rate a camera, you should rate it based on its functionality - i.e. how well does it perform?

    • Good: Picture quality is spectacular. At first, I downconverted the HDV --> DV and was quite impassive to the average picture quality. That was until I captured the HDV stream - it looked absolutely crystal clear... it's truly a shame that I can only enjoy this on my LCD monitor. But for those who already own a HD tv, you will be a fool not to shoot home movies with anything other than a HDV camera - and the HDR-HC3 is the ideal choice!
    • Bad: None.

      The only real distractor, as some have already mentioned, is the absence of some extras.

      For me, i would've appreciated the inclusion of a MemoryStick Duo and a carry case.
  • Faisal Aljundi gave 8/10 on 21/10/2006 03:49 Report abuse

    Excellent camcoder

    nice to have especially when you have HDTV

    • Good: clar picture
    • Bad: not easy to copy to PC or Recorder, at least there is no easy guide! especially for the HDV part. if I move it the video to PC or DVD, is it still HD or I lost it???
  • Anonymous gave 7/10 on 14/10/2006 08:22 Report abuse

    Beware of hidden Costs

    Great camera but if you wish to transfer that high definition footage to DVD you may be in for a rude shock. Sony does not supply software to transfer or edit with the unit. You must part with another $AU250 or so for that. There is no iLink (Firewire) cable so you may spend another $AU20 to $AU50. If you wish to keep it all on tapes you may be surprised that recommended Sony HD tapes are the most expensive on the market. Shop prices are about $AU35 each! So your expensive toy is now a very expensive, but very nice, toy.

    My advice is to wait for other brands of cameras and software to catch up. It won’t be long. It is a bit late for me. I had to pay because I had to use the camera for professional reasons and could not wait.

    Many sales people don’t know this and are genuinely staggered when it is pointed out to them and others are aware but keep very quiet until they sell the unit. As for me? Well… I was so used to obtaining a CD with electronic things that I took it for granted and this time got burned.

    Yes, I asked Sony about this. They are polite and pre-programmed, with a cyborg like response of “buyer beware”. They say that it is my responsibility to inform my self and not theirs to provide the information. I love to take it to the CEO or someone senior in the organisation but the “customer service” automats are a great “firewall”.

    Their solution, you ask? Well… they say get a IEEE cable and then use Microsoft Movie Maker after you convert from HD to standard definition (SD). Wait a minute.. did I just spend $500 over the odds to get a HD camera? As for falling back to Microsoft to provide a solution this, is just appalling.

    • Good: Nice camera, lite, small and high quality. High resolution video and still images.
    • Bad: Price is high, customer service is polite and probably autometed... don't bother.

Post your own

Submit

Enter your personal information to the left, or sign in with your Facebook account by clicking the button below.

Connect

Where to buy Sony HDR-HC3 HDV camcorder

See all options »

Must read

Advanced search

Product finder