The best-sounding MP3 players
By James Kim and Michael Degnan, CNET.com on 01 May 2006
Introduction | Signal-to-noise ratio | Distortion | Frequency response
Signal-to-noise ratio
Not surprisingly, the Creative Zen Vision:M came out on top of the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) heap. Basically, the higher the SNR, the less background hiss you'll perceive. The Creative Zen Vision:M has a rated SNR as high as 98dB, one of the most impressive figures we've seen or heard. Samsung's YP-Z5 and Cowon's iAudio X5 performed admirably, though humans will hardly notice the difference between the top nine players. We thought the more intriguing results were the relatively low SNRs of the Cowon iAudio U3 and the iRiver U10, both considered good-sounding players. Notice that the Apple iPod family has a relatively high SNR -- interesting because Apple doesn't publish iPod SNRs and because many users dog the iPod for its poor audio quality.
| Measured in dB |
Note: Products in this test are for comparative purposes only and are not all necessarily available in the Australian market.
Topics: apple, cowon, archos, psp, ipod, samsung, zen, creative, sony, mp3, players
Related Articles
Comments (3)
-
allen commented on 20/07/2009 10:11 Report abuse
hi there can u give the same information for itouch adn samsung-yp-p3
-
Neale commented on 13/09/2006 12:58 Report abuse
Essential data missing .. were the subjective tests carried out using the 'as-supplied' earbuds, or a standard pair?
-
Jason commented on 03/09/2006 05:30 Report abuse
Thanks for the very informative test. Hope to see some of the highly regarded and popular players included in the future such as, Inovix IMP604, Orb A3188, Sum Vision M18, iDisgo Lite, Elio M310 etc.
Post your own comment
Enter your personal information to the left, or sign in with your Facebook account by clicking the button below.
ConnectThe Explain Series
-
Whereis® maps
If you’d like to get to know more of Australia, and do it safely, then check out Whereis® maps.
-
Commonwealth Bank Mobile Banking
Bank anywhere, anytime. Learn more.
-
Nokia Navigation
The introduction of GPS adds a new dimension of 'social navigation'.
Must read
-
Fake iPod versus the real thing
CNET Australia's Shanghai correspondent heads down to the market and buys...
-
Creative Zen X-Fi2 32GB
The Creative Zen X-Fi2 is the company's first touchscreen MP3 player which...
-
Fake iPod Nano (4th generation)
If it wasn't for the glitchy software and sub-standard battery life, the...
-
Apple iPod Touch (3rd generation, 32GB)
Though the updates are subtle, the third-generation iPod Touch still...
-
Creative's drastic price drop on unreleased MP3
The player hasn't even started shipping yet, but Creative has already...









3%
3%



