Top 5 VoIP Myths

By Asher Moses on 04 July 2006

Asher Moses, CNET.com.aucommentary Since publishing our "Is it time to ditch your landline" feature, which takes a look at Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) and its viability as a regular landline replacement, a number of general misconceptions have been brought to our attention. This was particularly apparent when we took part in a recent radio segment on the subject for ABC radio, during which questions from confused listeners were fielded by CNET.com.au.

Below are our top five VoIP misconceptions and why they're wrong:

  1. VoIP calls are free - While VoIP calls between two PCs are free, if you're looking to call a landline phone, you'll have to pony up. Fortunately, this is much cheaper than a fixed line rate; on average, VoIP local/STD calls are untimed and cost just 10 cents, while a similar Telstra fixed line call will set you back approximately 20c per minute.

  2. VoIP lines can survive electrical blackouts - Unlike your regular telephone line, when the electricity to your home cuts out, so too does your Internet connection and thus, your VoIP line.

  3. Landline numbers are easily ported over to a VoIP service - If you decide to take the plunge to VoIP, chances are you'll need to live with using a new phone number. Each VoIP user is provided with a unique telephone number, however, relationships between traditional fixed line vendors and VoIP providers are far from strong, so porting numbers is difficult.

  4. Calls can only be made from in front of a computer - Although this was the case when VoIP first emerged, the recent emergence of wireless VoIP handsets and telephone adaptors provides VoIP users with just as much freedom as they'd have with a fixed line phone.

  5. Dial-up Internet is sufficient - If you want call quality to be anywhere near the level of your regular landline, the low bandwidth of a dialup connection just won't cut it. At least a 512kbps broadband plan is preferable, and if you're looking to ditch your landline, a cable, satellite or wireless broadband solution should be picked over ADSL.

A more thorough explanation of VoIP in Australia can be found in our "VoiP explained" feature.

Have you taken the plunge to VoIP yet? If so, is it a viable landline replacement? If not, why not? Talk back to us below.

Topics: voip, engin, freshtel, mynetphone, voice-over-ip, skype

Related Articles

Comments (12)

  • Mojo commented on 27/10/2009 17:28

    Hey I'm wondering can I use my landline to recieve calls and voip to make them as I do not wish to change my number and my house is not compatible for naked ADSL 2.

  • Candour tech commented on 04/08/2009 09:06

    Interesting point from Mike. VoIP is OK for calling your granny in the UK or whatever but, having analysed many bills for many companies, the main call cost is to mobile phones. VoIP providers are not generally cheap in this area.
    The trick is to use a telephone adaptor that can have voip and your landline plugged into it...this way you can sned international and long distance calls out via VoIP and mobile calls out via th landline. Plus, get a plan with someone other than Telstra...there are many out there with far bettre rates!

  • patientlady commented on 01/10/2008 15:20

    I've been with Adam Talk for 3 months now and boy, what an odyssee this was! Anything that could go wrong went wrong and until TODAY I could not get calls because they couldn't hear me, then the echo was so strong on one side, then calls would be directed immediatly to the voice mail, and and the problem was mostly the program my son used to down/upload stuff. It used almost all the bandwidth there was, even when it wasn't downloading it would interfere. So, between the software company and the server and heaps of expensive mobile phone calls it was finally solved! Now, to eliminate the echo for the caller I thought about getting an ATA when I realised the modem only has one ethernet port! I hate headphones which would eliminate the echo (but strangely when using Skype there's no echo). So, what to do? I am just glad the thing works. Would I do it again? Not so sure. Haven't saved a cent so far, due to heavy use of mobile phone. I hope all of this will work itself out now.

  • jack_frost_esq commented on 29/07/2008 21:24

    Skype now has a $5.95 AU per month service that allows free calls to land lines within australia.
    Found it works great as I have the same account on my home computer and on my pda. Cheap as chips.

  • Bazzel commented on 24/06/2008 14:32

    simvegas... exactly my point!

  • simvegas commented on 04/03/2008 17:49

    hahaha at#5.
    yep try making a voip call on satellite and tell me how ugo.

  • D commented on 18/10/2007 13:43

    Point 2 is somewhat fixable. If you're really worried about making phone calls when the power is out you can attach the broadband modem and other VOIP devices to a UPS. UPS's aren't all that expensive these days.

    http://daedalus-geek.freehostia.com

  • Plastic Druid commented on 15/08/2007 20:01

    It's true that you can't make VoIP calls in a power cut but if you have a mobile what's the problem? We have two teenage kids and our household has four mobiles. We ditched our landline six months ago and don't miss it at all. In fact, getting a new telephone number was great because the telemarketers don't bother us anymore.

  • Mike commented on 08/03/2007 10:36

    Engin is not all it's cracked up to be.

    Our analysis shows we saved exactly $4 on our average $400 monthly bill, not worth the hassle!!! Calls to mobiles are more expensive then the rate we had with Telstra. Calls to their own customer service (a so called local call rate 1300 number) are charged at 28cents. You cannot block caller ID (explaination from Engin: "we have some problems with that at the moment" 5 weeks??!!!) Record wait for customer service = 34 minutes, and were then referred to website, the info wasn't there, back to customer service (19 min wait), "oh, that's right we changed that page.") Because of the 2 numbers (landline and engin) heaps of missed calls on the landline number... and so it goes on.

    Back to Telstra for landline and Go-Talk for overseas.

  • Terry Donnelly commented on 12/11/2006 13:13

    I have been using Freshtel for some months now on the cheapest plan. Most of the time it works well but long calls invariably start breaking up and eventually drop out altogether. This is true with both the softphone and the telephone adaptor linked with a Uniden cordless phone. The softphone is a little more reliable but nowhere as convenient. I am using an Exetel plan with 512 download.

Post your own comment

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 & A..F

Submit

Enter your personal information to the left, or sign in with your Facebook account by clicking the button below.

Connect

The Explain Series

Must read

Popular Phones & Plans

Powered by WhistleOut

1) Apple iPhone 3GS 32GB36 plans 1%
2) Apple iPhone 3GS 16GB36 plans 1%
3) Nokia N9743 plans 2%
4) Nokia E7149 plans 1%
5) Sony Ericsson Satio14 plans 4%
Three Vodafone
« 1 of »
1) Apple mobile phones 3%
2) Nokia mobile phones 4%
3) Sony Ericsson mobile phones 5%
4) Samsung mobile phones 1%
5) Blackberry mobile phones 2%

Compare: Mobiles | Broadband

CNET Australia Partner Services