Whaddyareckon?: Home theatre vs movie theatre

By Matt Oxley on 30 May 2008

Tags: movies | whaddyareckon | theatre | cinema

Get Adobe Flash player

An outing to the cinema is a good night out for all. Watching an epic flick from a comfy seat, equipped with a bucket of cola and a trough of popcorn: what's not to love?

Well, perhaps the mobile phones that pierce the darkness with shrill ringtone versions of top 40 hits. Or those irritating kids that talk through the whole thing. Or that guy who rustles his Twisties bag so often that it must be intentional. Come to think of it, a trip to the flicks is traumatic for everyone. In this age of huge plasma tellies, Blu-ray and at-home Dolby, why do we still go?

In this week's Whaddyareckon? we ask whether people still hanker for the communal movie experience, or if they prefer to get their movie kicks in the privacy of their own abode.

Do you still fork over the cash for cinema tickets, or is your living room the only theatre you'll ever need? Tell us in the new Whaddyareckon? forum.

Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

canberra_photographer
canberra_photographer
30/05/2008 05:59 PM

There's no competition. The special acoustic properties of cinemas coupled with a ground rumbling array of speakers and subs are in a different league to the often dinky $400 5.1 set-ups consumers have. The screen is just a tad bigger in the cinema. And even if we can watch the movies at home, it takes 4-8 months for it to be released on disc. Why wait to pay $50 for the movie (more than the movie tickets) only to watch it on a TV. The cinema isn't just for watching the film like you would at home, it's an experience in itself.

Report offensive content

trevor67
31/05/2008 11:08 AM

I much prefer my home cinema - Pioneer LX508A and surround sound - better picture, better sound and no annoying crowd

Report offensive content

Flick
31/05/2008 08:19 PM

C_photo - you've got to be kiddin', a decent HD projector, quality 5.1+ or above sound and bittorrent / usenet and you've got the latest and greatest on a budget - spend a bitmore and you can rival / better the pro's - knowledge is the key to a better experience and an investment to the home!

Report offensive content

Matthew Hodgson
01/06/2008 07:16 PM

I've got a great cinema setup at home. When ever I think about going to the movies I have to take into consideration whether the 'experience' of the big screen is going to be better. In most circumstances, my sound setup at home is far better than many cinemas around town. It means, in the end, I only go to the cinema when I'm going to watch big block-busters with digital sound.

Report offensive content

ac
02/06/2008 12:24 PM

I agree with Matt. Most movies don't need to be seen in the cinema. ESPECIALLY CHICK FLIX. summer blockbusters like Iron Man, Transformers and Indiana Jones though are a different story. Nothing compares to seeing Optimus Prime transforming at the Bondi Junction Greater Union cinema

Report offensive content

Preest
02/06/2008 04:07 PM

Cinemas are overrated in my opinion. My home theatre with an 80 inch screen and 2200 watts (discrete) of 7.1 surround sound is better than any mainstream movie theatre. What i've noticed at the theatre is that the films are often grainy and they never crank up the sound. Remember that a movie is a visual and aural experience, so if you have a nice big screen and mediocre sound coming from the speakers, it ruins the experience. Just my 2 cents worth on the subject.

Report offensive content

askec01
02/06/2008 04:36 PM

It's a no-brainer. I have a 200 inch screen with a high def in ceiling projector accompanied by a 6.1 channel surround sound. I have the best seat in the house all the time every time, the movie starts when I am ready and I get a break whenever I want one, the toilets are always clean and I am allowed to take hot snacks back to my seat. Home theatre.....priceless.

Report offensive content

Gotaclue
02/06/2008 08:22 PM

Anyone ever been on a date? See how much harder it is to ask a girl you've just met to watch a movie at your place than it is to go see a movie on neutral (and public) ground. Just one of the many reasons the cinema will never die - because the enjoying the movie itself is playing second fiddle to its social role.

Report offensive content

donaldi
03/06/2008 04:50 AM

How about looking at it from another angle? For many years I love going to the cinema despite my hearing (nerve deafness) problems. Nowadays the films are often rather grainy prints, projection problems, people chatting and slurping, and paying rather high adnission fees. Now with home cinema and a 50" LCD TV playing DVD's with subtitles and listening via headphones (sound being re-directed to others) this is so much better; bliss indeed! In a few years home cinema will soon pay for itself in setting it up.

Report offensive content

pitufon
03/06/2008 12:50 PM

the cinema experience is so much different to that at home - try watching a good comedy where you have 200 people just cracking up as opposed to whatever groups you can fit in your lounge - or the fright that you get from "the others" when you hear the skreetching noise out of the closet - as much as i have a great setup at home - the whole experience cant be compared

Report offensive content

fhuckYOURshhweatyBalls
03/06/2008 02:01 PM

I think its great that you can make your own videos at home, but cmon, nothing beats a night out socially watching a movie eating the butter saturated popcorn, laught with the reast, they both are good, but the cinema is completely different!

Report offensive content

AusRom
15/06/2008 11:23 AM

I stopped going to the Cinema some time ago because there was always some moron in the crowd that would ruin the experience in some respect. The home cinema I have now allows my partner and I, 4 of our close friends to enjoy movies in style and comfort. It also doubles as a large console/PC gaming room. I have no need for a cinema any more.

Report offensive content

jgrant83
24/07/2008 05:02 PM

I have an HD projector at home but anyone who says their digital tv or projector can compete with 35mm film projection should stop making out with their tv and wake up to a real cinema experience

Report offensive content

Ben
25/07/2008 03:25 PM

The community experience of going to the theatre beats watching a movie at home everytime. When you go to the cinema's you have a diferent mindset, you drove there, found parking, and everything else with the explicit purpose of watching a particular film. That in itself means you focu on the movie more and enjoy it more. Whereas at home you often pause a film and get up and do something else quickly, at the cinema you wait until the last moment to go to the toilet because you don't want to leave. Watching comedies is always better in a cinema, because you laugh out loud for real with 100 other people. That shared experience is something I love. Also I love turning off my phone, and disconnecting from the world for the 2 hours i'm in there. I also think tits a bit of a myth that there's always annoying peolple in the movie. Doesn't happen to me often. Either you cinema needs better security, or you're focusing on other stuff. Like a previous poster said too. I don't care if you spent 20 grand on a home theatre, it doesn't beat a 35mm print. That's my ramble of the day done.

Report offensive content

  • Leave a comment

All fields marked with * are required

What do you think

Your e-mail will not be displayed

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars.


  • HD Olympics: A look behind the scenes

  • Best 1080p televisions

  • How Seven blew the internet Olympics

  • Samsung LA40A650

  • Toshiba Regza 42AV500A

  • LG Scarlet 42LG61YD

  • Oi!: Getting a complex(ion) over high definition

  • Sony Bravia KDL46W4000

  • Sharp LC46D83X

More articles »

Product finder

The Explain Series

  • Samsung LA40A650

    Samsung LA40A650

    The Samsung LA40A650 is a very good all-rounder which particularly shines in high definition, but it's facing some talented competition.

  • Toshiba Regza 42AV500A

    Toshiba Regza 42AV500A

    The Toshiba Regza 42AV500A is a great mid-range unit with an attractive price point. It's not perfect but it will certainly please the budget consumer.

  • LG Scarlet 42LG61YD

    LG Scarlet 42LG61YD

    The LG Scarlet 42LG61YD is an exceptional 1080p television with great design, features and a well implemented 100Hz mode. Considering the cost and the improvements over the previous Scarlet, this is definitely a good buy.

  • Sony Bravia KDL46W4000

    Sony Bravia KDL46W4000

    The Sony Bravia 46W4000 offers exceptional image and sound quality at a reasonable price.

  • Sharp LC46D83X

    Sharp LC46D83X

    The Sharp LC46D83X boasts high levels of black and imparts a real sense of depth, but interlacing problems over moving images spoil the party.

More reviews »

Membership benefits

Create wishlists

Create wishlists

See a product on CNET.com.au that you want? Add it to your wishlist and send a hint to your friends and family. Sign up for a free CNET.com.au membership now!