In a cinema in Los Angeles, 86 years ago, the first 3D feature film was shown to a paying audience. While almost no-one remembers The Power of Love now, it was the tentative steps of a technology which enjoyed its Golden Age during the 50's. Even Hitchcock filmed a 3D feature (in Dial M for Murder).
Samsung is one company that is trying to bring some of the magic back with its new 3D plasmas, the PS42A450 and the PS50A450.
Upside
We've seen 3D done before, and not particularly successfully in Zalman's gaming monitor. Samsung has attempted to alleviate the problems by incorporating an infrared emitter into the glasses that tells the system where you are and adjusts the 3D effect accordingly. No more playing around with PC drivers for hours.
Of course, there's one stumbling block which we'll discuss shortly — the 3D effect needs a PC to work. At present it's mostly games that are supported, though there is at least one Stereoscopic movie player available on the Net — this means you'll also need a stereoscopic video to watch it on. These are hard to come by.
Apart from the 3D functionality, the plasma sits in the company's budget Series 4 range and includes a 1024 by 768 resolution — the 50-inch has 1365 by 768 — plus a "true" 30,000:1 contrast ratio and three HDMI connections. Being a plasma, the PS42A450P1 also features several different technologies which Samsung says "ensures that no images are burned into your plasma panel".
Downside
We cannot convey to you in words how ugly the spectacles are that you need to enable the 3D effect. They look like they should be accompanied with a certificate for Licence 3 Butt Fusion Welding — and yes that's actually what they call it.
Major downside: not only do you need to connect your TV to a computer for 3D, but the computer needs an Nvidia graphics card (which most notebooks won't have) and the game needs to support it. As we found previously with the Zalman monitor, some games are more successful than others.
The 42-inch also has two other downsides: one, the resolution needs to downscale HD images due to its limited 1024 by 768, which could lead to reduced picture quality; and two, the TV only features an analog tuner.
Outlook
We don't see many people who buy these TVs actually using the 3D capability, especially given all the caveats involved, but it's an interesting value-add nonetheless.
Like anything, it'll be price that determines whether this TV is a good deal, especially if you need to buy the glasses separately. We expect pricing to be available closer to the June release date.
Enterfrize
08/05/2008, 01:34 PM
rating
8/10
Dear Ty,
I can't speak for the product itself, but I think this review didn't go deep enough. Hollywood is taking on 3D cinema in a big way thanks to 2:1 and 3:1 revenue compared to 2D offerings. You are correct to place great emphasis on stereoscopic 3D (S-3D) gaming because that is very exciting. We also have to credit the huge amount of growing pressure for this new 3D movie content to be equally displayed at home.
On the gaming side, Electronic Arts via their Electronic Arts Korea division is already taking a serious interest in stereoscopic 3D (S-3D) as shown here:
http://mtbs3d.com/cgi-bin/rss_interviews.cgi?news_id=40
http://mtbs3d.com/cgi-bin/rss_interviews.cgi?news_id=52
We are starting to see game developers implement native stereoscopic 3D support, and many of the leading game developers (e.g. Epic Games, Ubisoft, Turbine Games, etc.) have submitted titles for stereoscopic 3D review.
For myself, I'm not interested in what the glasses look like. I'm interested in reading about how the content looks through the glasses. 2:1 and 3:1 Hollywood cinema revenue was never dependent on how good the eyewear looked.
It would be good if you could amend your review with content experiences like S-3D movies, games, etc.
Regardless, it is good to see CNET taking an interest in these exciting stereoscopic 3D technologies.
Thanks in advance,
Neil Schneider, President & CEO
Meant to be Seen
http://www.mtbs3D.com
Pros: N/A
Cons: N/A
Report offensive comment