WD My Book Home Edition 500GB

By Ty Pendlebury on 17 March 2008

The WD My Book Home Edition 500GB is a cost-effective external hard drive which offers a flexible set of connections, but it's not very fast.

Editor's rating:7.0 User rating:3.5
  • Good: Choice of interfaces • Quiet • Value for money •
  • Bad: Lacking performance •
  • Specs: 500 GB • eSATA, USB 2.0, FireWire 400 • Mac, PC • 480 Mbps • See more specifications
  • RRP: AU$199.00

With hard drive prices crashing to crazy levels, now is as good a time as any to invest in additional storage. Western Digital has updated its external range, and it includes this new My Book Home Edition 500GB drive.

In keeping with the theme, the drive is shaped like a book, with the familiar slotted cooling vents representing the "pages". The round power light of old has been replaced with a dim blue bar, which works in the same way by roughly displaying the amount of storage space available. This is divided into four different segments and requires the installation of a dedicated driver.

The My Book offers inputs akimbo with two FireWire ports (one 400 and one 800), an eSATA and a USB port. Though there is a FireWire and a USB cable in the package unfortunately there's no eSATA cable included. On a side note: finding an eSATA cable could also prove difficult -- we had to visit four different local computer stores before we found one.

The drive ships with a tonne of software which includes Memeo AutoSync, various Google apps, a "copy application software" tool, and the WD Anywhere backup program.

The drive didn't perform as well as the WD's own My Book Premium ES Edition which you can find cheaper online. Using the standard USB cable we were able to get a 21.9 MB/s read speed, which is slower than the Premium's 28.4 MB/s. Using eSATA we were able to get a more respectable 48.6 MB/s speed, but this was still slower than the Premium's 66.4 MB/s score.

Topics: my book, wd, western digital, 500gb, esata, usb, external, hard drive, book, cable

Comments (4)

  • NathanB2 gave 2/10 on 12/09/2009 15:22 Report abuse

    • Good: Bought it on sale for dirt cheap. Better than Segate or Maxtor.
    • Bad: They must have cheaped out on the internal components when they upgraded the look of the drives.

    Terrible waste of good files. I bought this expecting it to last as long as the older style WD mybook hard drives. Sadly however, this wasn't the case. The hard drive became corrupted, and running scan disc on it didn't do any good at all. Most of my folders turned into 32kb blank icons. After that, I ran some type of WD test on the drive (test reported error) Ran scan disk again, and then was unable to access any information on the drive at all. Rather sad that I bought an extended warranty on this drive from Officemax, and the drive fried out before WD's warranty even expired. I didn't bother to waste my money buying another extended warranty on the replacement drive. I can only hope that this drive will last long enough for me to backup everything important before it totally dies like the last one of these that I returned today. Sad to say, but I think WD hard drives are decreasing in quality.

  • TGP gave 1/10 on 01/03/2009 09:19 Report abuse

    • Good: It looks like a book is inconspicuous on my desk.
    • Bad: The WED Anywhere Backup software which is included for free actually is not. WD asked $30 for use beyond 30 days. The software application did not run out of the box. After downloading current software Ia was able to make the software run however it did not recognize the installed WD drive that it came with. The eSATA interface was extraordinarily slow taking over 1 hour to back up 4 Gig. I ended up returning this product.

    Do not trust valuable backup to a product so haphazardly developed.

  • jdripper gave 9/10 on 07/07/2008 10:36 Report abuse

    • Good: Nice appearance - matches the PS3. Works great with my Norton Ghost.
    • Bad: Doesn't work with USB 1.1

    Works great so far!

  • FormerWDCustomer gave 2/10 on 07/04/2008 16:38 Report abuse

    • Good: cheap
    • Bad: breaks

    Failed right after the warranty expired. This is not unusual, the MyBook line is plagued by failure problems, google it and you'll see thousands of complaints. WD, for its part, will replace the busted drives - but the warranty doesn't cover data recovery. STAY AWAY!!!

Post your own

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 & A..F

Submit

Enter your personal information to the left, or sign in with your Facebook account by clicking the button below.

Connect

The Explain Series

Where to buy WD My Book Home Edition 500GB

See all options »

Must read

Advanced search

Product finder

Recently viewed products