What's left for Apple's OS X to grab from iOS?

View more from Apple »

Apple's new version of OS X, dubbed Mountain Lion, brings a number of features over from iOS, but a few big ones have yet to make the trip.

Mountain Lion
(Credit: Apple/CNET)

Apple's upcoming Mountain Lion software update for the Mac certainly isn't bashful about borrowing features from iOS, but what the company chose not to add is a story in itself.

The release is largely a collection of new software that came with iOS 5, the software that Apple released for the iPhone, iPad and iPod Touch in October. That includes software like Reminders, iMessage and Notification Center, all of which now come pre-installed on the Mac and ready to sync up with their iOS counterparts.

But not everything came along for the ride. There are still a handful of features that Apple has left out. Below are four notable omissions.

Note: Apple says that Mountain Lion is still a work in progress, and that features may change ahead of its release. There could also be a surprise or two that weren't ready to go in the demo.

iPhone's Siri
(Credit: Apple)


Siri, the voice-assistant feature introduced as part of the iPhone 4S, is not a part of the Mountain Lion preview. That's a curious thing, given Siri's role on the iPhone 4S. There, it's tied into a handful of apps that are now a part of Mountain Lion, including Notes, Reminders and Messages, as well as software that was there in previous OS X iterations, like Mail, FaceTime and Apple's Dashboard widgets for checking the weather and stock prices.

But bringing the voice-assistant feature to the desktop likely presents a challenge to Apple. Would people feel comfortable talking to their computer, versus something like a phone, where they're used to speaking into it to make phone calls? More importantly, Siri is really a feature that's about skipping people beyond having to fumble to unlock their phone, find an app and start pecking away. On a computer, there are fewer of these hurdles.

But if it were to be added, how much run of the system do you give it? On the iPhone, the Siri software is strongly limited from doing much more than helping you with search queries, and creating and editing alarms and appointments. Two things it can't do are launch software programs and help you find files — tasks that people would be likely to want to use it for on the Mac.


iBooks on the iPad.
(Credit: Apple)

Perhaps one of the most glaring omissions in Mountain Lion is the iBooks application. You can throw this into the pile of things that might come in the final release, and is simply not part of this developer preview, but it's peculiar. Apple has a vested interest in expanding the utility of its iBookstore, and the purchases that people have made on it.

When asked why this wasn't in there during a briefing last week, the company provided no answer, nor any indication as to whether iBooks might arrive at a later date.

Competitor Amazon has run laps around Apple when it comes to ebook availability, bringing versions of its Kindle reading app to multiple platforms — including mobile phones and in the form of native desktop applications on Windows and Mac. Last year, the company took it one step further, launching its reader as a web app that runs in the browser.

Another reason why I'd expect to see iBooks on the Mac — at least eventually — is that Apple's got an unusual situation on its hands in the sense that people can now create books for the platform on a Mac, but still can't really see how they look. Last month, Apple released the iBooks Author software as a way for people to create books and text books, but the software requires the user to own an iPad in order to be able to give their creations a test run. A proper reading application would solve this problem.

Newsstand on the iPad.
(Credit: Scott Stein/CNET)


Part of the iBooks/iBookstore ecosystem, Newsstand is the iOS 5-specific feature that lets people read and subscribe to newspapers and magazines that get both delivered and updated in an organised fashion. The obvious reason why it's not a part of the Mountain Lion preview would seem to be that the feature was designed largely to corral news-reading apps and self-updating magazines. On a Mac, people can get that same news through the browser, and magazines haven't taken hold in app form, like they have on Apple's iPad.

Still, the same argument about Apple having a vested interest in bringing a way to view iBooks content on the Mac holds true with this. It's a chicken-and-egg problem, in that there truly needs to be something built for the publishers to come. The bigger question is whether Apple would introduce iBooks for the Mac without bringing Newsstand along.

iCloud back-up feature on iOS.
(Credit: Josh Lowensohn/CNET)

iCloud back-up/restore

One feature introduced in iOS 5 that is not present in Mountain Lion's preview is a built-in back-up and restoration from iCloud. On iOS, this lets you take a nightly snapshot of your gadget for safe storage on Apple's servers. You can then recover the copy back to that device, or to another one anywhere that you have an internet connection.

On something like a notebook or desktop, Apple has treated this back-up need with Time Machine, a more advanced tool that takes multiple snapshots of your entire computer's file system, and lets you make a full restoration, or just grab a copy of a particular file at a particular time.

The limitation with Time Machine is that you need to be plugged in to a hard drive or wireless storage device (like Apple's Time Capsule) to make those off-computer back-ups; you can't just connect to Apple's servers. Apple does, however, offer a built-in Internet Recovery feature that will return your computer to the stock version of Mac OS X.

The simple reason why that isn't here is space. iCloud was designed to store and ferry over individual files and settings, but the available storage there is nowhere near close to what desktop users might need for Time Machine-style back-ups. For instance, its low-end plans bring the storage up to 15GB at a price of $20 per year, maxing out at $100 a year for the 55GB plan. By comparison, Apple's entry-level notebook, the MacBook Air, ships with 64GB of built-in storage.

Apple has taken some steps here with deeper integration of storing those files in iCloud, but it's a different paradigm from the comprehensive solution found with Time Machine. Will something like that arrive sometime in a future version of OS X? Perhaps, but don't count on it in Mountain Lion.


Add Your Comment


Be the first to comment on this story!

Post comment as

Sponsored Links

Recently Viewed Products