Where in the World is Carmen Sandiego?

Where in the World is Carmen Sandiego fails to maintain the charm of previous versions and a lack of variation leaves it feeling dull and unsatisfying.


4.0
CNET Rating
2.0
User Rating


The Carmen Sandiego series was a staple of 90's adventure and puzzle-solving gaming, so the chance to return to those heady days on the DS was one we didn't want to miss. Unfortunately, while the new iteration preserves some aspects of the PC originals, it fails to maintain the charm that was the most notable characteristic of the series. The characters are not engaging and the dialogue dull, with some occasional sexual innuendo that seems wildly out of place in a game aimed at children. This is compounded by the various characters feeling very close to racial caricatures, both of which undercut the attempts to position the game as semi-educational.

The graphics are clean and clear, but they lack flair. Everything looks nice enough, presented in classic Carmen Sandiego style, with good delineation between background and foreground objects. Characters stand out from pretty backgrounds in what is essentially the exact same visual style of the original games, as well as the cartoons some readers may fondly remember. Everything looks exactly as you'd expect in a puzzle game for kids — which makes the more "adult" dialogue stand out even more.

In previous Carmen Sandiego games, the integration of the information about the places and people you meet in the game with the puzzles was a fairly important part of the gameplay, but here it just feels tacked on, more like an afterthought than a genuine attempt to include an educational aspect. In fact, there's almost no reason to read any of the tiny amounts of text describing where you're headed.

We might have been a little less concerned about this if the core game wasn't so weak. There aren't all that many puzzles in the game and the only challenging ones are those that require trial and error because you aren't given enough information. This is compounded by the puzzles being uninteresting, mostly consisting of stabbing the stylus at every object on the screen until you access them in the order the game wants you to. This ranges from trying to work out which book on a shelf is the correct one to tapping every item in a lab in a desperate attempt to determine which ones have been arbitrarily set as usable.

The notable exception is the fingerprint collection mini-game, which involves using the stylus as a brush to spread dust on a surface then blowing the dust off, by blowing into the microphone. Unfortunately, you only do this once, and none of the subsequent investigations include anything that has the same degree of simple fun.

The use of the DS's external hardware is otherwise unremarkable, continuing the obligatory use of the second screen, which feels forced, while the buttons have no role in the actual gameplay, leaving the stylus to do all the work. This is a sensible choice, in that point-and-click has always been the style of the Carmen Sandiego games, but given how little goes on in the game, some use of the other controls might have livened up the experience.

The issue of the dialogue being age-inappropriate really permeates the whole game. While clearly aimed at a younger audience in terms of the rather low difficulty, the dialogue and instructions don't really lend themselves to a children's game. The clunky back and forth that passes as witty repartee is of a notably adult tone, though not a very clever one. It becomes a little difficult to tell what demographic the game targets — the simplicity of the challenges suggests a young audience, but the content seems more "young adult". Usually our litmus test is to give the game to a child and get their response, but we weren't sure that the content was all that appropriate, despite the game's "General" rating, so we decided to use a teenager as the lab rat and were unsurprised to be given the game back, sans DS, while they kept themselves better entertained via the console's in-built camera.

Where in the World is Carmen Sandiego? is a frustrating game because while nothing is actually bad (though a few elements do come close) the whole package feels overwhelmingly mediocre. While it isn't really terrible, it's unimaginative, dull and unsatisfying.

Previous Story

Maestro! Jump in Music

Games
Next Story

Band Hero (DS)



Add Your Review 2


* Below fields optional


Post comment as
mark
1
Rating
 

mark posted a review   

The Good:nothing

The Bad:was not like the computer game

was not very hard puzzle game to solve and no need to play twice as there is only one story line outcome

Jeff
3
Rating
 

Jeff posted a review   

The Good:Visuals were bright and somewhat appealing

The Bad:Awkward gameplay mechanics, Clunky Dialogue, Lazy Design

The joy of playing the 'Where in ... is Carmen Sandiego' series comes from the sense of accomplishment you feel from piecing together various pieces of information and in doing so maybe finding out something new about the world you live in... This involved using problem-solving logic and geographical cues to chase and find the elusive carmen. This handheld Niintendo DS game is a brilliant concept, poorly executed. The incorporation of the stylus seems like an excellent idea until you find yourself prodding over the same desk fifteen times to get a response. As the reviewer stated the educational element seems tacked on, as does the gameplay - the centerpiece being an unengaging plot filled with stereotypical caricatures and inappropriate dialogue. This in turn robs you of any feeling of accomplishment as the sleuthing takes a back seat to the god-awful amount of elongated cut-scenes. This was a massive disappointment for me. I ended up wishing the developers just ported the original title to the DS.

...

I'm hoping sometime in the future they do, because this generation of kids is missing out on a fantastic game. Kids, don't let this game put you off the rest of the series.




Sponsored Links

Recently Viewed Products